Roll With Joe
+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 19

Thread: Consolation races

  1. #1
    aussiebreno
    Guest

    Consolation races

    The fascination with big money consolation races has to end.

    They are a consolation, not nearly as big as the main thing.

    Abettorpunt beaten 27m in Inter heat. Won $60,000 for what is really the Inter consolation. Monifeith picked up $15K for 2nd. Restrepo, Keayang Cullen, Mach Beauty gave them other two a towel up in the heats, yet only got $15K prizemoney in the real thing.

    The APG consolation winner this week gets a cool $25K. That is more than the 4th horse in the final. When you have Purdons, Thackerays and McCarthys filly in the race (not to mention quite a few other nice fillies) 4th is going to be a damn good result. Yet the 11th best filly gets more prizemoney than the 4th best filly. It doesn't seem fair to me.

  2. #2
    Senior Member Horse Of The Year mightymo will become famous soon enough
    Real Name
    Harvey Kaplan
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    647
    Horses
    Bling It On, Nike Franco, Cruz Bromac
    Quote Originally Posted by aussiebreno View Post
    The fascination with big money consolation races has to end.

    They are a consolation, not nearly as big as the main thing.

    Abettorpunt beaten 27m in Inter heat. Won $60,000 for what is really the Inter consolation. Monifeith picked up $15K for 2nd. Restrepo, Keayang Cullen, Mach Beauty gave them other two a towel up in the heats, yet only got $15K prizemoney in the real thing.

    The APG consolation winner this week gets a cool $25K. That is more than the 4th horse in the final. When you have Purdons, Thackerays and McCarthys filly in the race (not to mention quite a few other nice fillies) 4th is going to be a damn good result. Yet the 11th best filly gets more prizemoney than the 4th best filly. It doesn't seem fair to me.
    i have to agree with you Brendan. Im all for having a consolation race, BUT last place in the main race has to be worth more than first place in the consolation.

    PS - the consolation race is also a Gr 2!

  3. #3
    Senior Member 2YO Bonnie will become famous soon enough
    Real Name
    Anne Anderson
    Location
    Melbourne Victoria
    Occupation
    Horse Breeder /Owner
    Posts
    172
    Horses
    Ladies In Red, Hurricane Harley, Honolua
    I too have an issue with the APG Consolation Race for the 2 year old fillies. I am quoting from th APG Terms and Conditions Of Race Series 24. " Section 9.0 CONSOLATION FINALS - FOR HORSES THAT COMPETED IN THE SEMI - FINALS BUT FAILED TO QUALIFY FOR THE FINAL. One Consolation Final per sex shall be conducted for horses that competed in the semi finals but failed to qualify for the Final. The Consolation Final for each sex shall be conducted in the same State as the Final."

    There are 2 horses in the 2 year old fillies Consolation Final @ Menangle ( Race 2 ) on Sunday that did not even contest a heat let alone a semi final. I refer to Priority Pass and Sunshine Hannigan. There are 8 fillies who have raced in accordance with the above conditions and have earned their right to contest the Consolation. Eight horses constitute a field and no further nominations should have been sought by APG. However, under Clause 15 ( I assume ) the Board Of Directors of APG decided to run the Consolation with a full field and invited nominations. Clause 15 basically gives Directors the right to do as they please.

    I see no valid reason for the inclusion of these 2 fillies. They have received a " free shot ' at a $50,000 race. They had their opportunity to nominate and contest a heat in their home State and as they chose not to , they should be ineligible for the Consolation. Why should they receive preferential treatment? They come into this race fresh, whereas some other fillies and their trainers/ stablehands travelled from interstate to contest the semis last Saturday night and have had to remain in NSW for next Sundays racing. Owners of these fillies have incurred considerable costs and have done everything in accordance with the rules.

    In my opionion APG have a lot to answer for . There are many disgruntled owners who question their decision to pay up for these races when you don't get a fair go.

  4. #4
    Super Moderator Stallion Richard prior will become famous soon enough Richard prior's Avatar
    Real Name
    Richard Prior
    Location
    Sydney
    Occupation
    Gas Operator
    Posts
    1,516
    Horses
    Intransit
    Great topic Breno, I was going to be a little more generous until Harvey and Anne commented. First of all, Totally agree with Harvey, APG could have easily taken $20,000 off the Consolation and put more into the Gold Final field, There's no way a winner of the Consolation should receive more than the last place horse in the APG final, I also have a problem with the Group status of the race, Probably should be a Group 3 at the Maximum. Sure there would be hard luck story's from the Heats and Semi's but all horses have had more than one chance to strut their stuff. There would be room for the placegetters from 6th to 10th in the main race to earn the equivalent of what the winner of the Consolation would receive. I have to fully agree with Anne as well, Where does the APG board of directors get off including 2 wild cards who haven't competed in any of the lead up races, They should be ineligible for the final and I would be more inclined to have the eight horses in the Consolation and pay $2000 from 6th to 8th and this would be a far better option for the owners and trainers who have battled on in the heats and semi's.
    Last edited by Richard prior; 04-24-2014 at 12:20 AM.

  5. #5
    Senior Member Stallion Danno is a jewel in the rough
    Real Name
    Dan Gibson
    Location
    Hunter Valley NSW Australia
    Occupation
    Driving 175:1 winners!
    Posts
    1,153
    Horses
    No Stars
    I'm inclined to disagree with you all,

    Firstly, a consolation race is "exactly" that...had no luck in the heats, heres another chance to earn some $$ for being involved in the series. The arguement that 6th to 10th in the final should get more than the winner of a consolation is basically the work of elitists...it's a consolation...what about the horses that are very talented but were "shortened up", "knocked over" or just had no luck in running at all???? Have the owners of those horses not paid up for the series?? have they not paid up for their training/vet/farrier etc, etc.....people, take a moment, the world is not designed just for your benefit.

    In relation to the horses that were included late,how can you validly claim they have had a "free shot" they have obviously paid their fees to be included in the series, but you people would deny them the chance to get something back??, these horses were not laying around in the paddock, the owners of these horses have incurred similar costs to yours so where do you think they have not earned the right of inclusion????

    Greed is a growing issue in our society, as is elitism.

  6. #6
    aussiebreno
    Guest
    Quote Originally Posted by Danno View Post
    I'm inclined to disagree with you all,

    Firstly, a consolation race is "exactly" that...had no luck in the heats, heres another chance to earn some $$ for being involved in the series. The arguement that 6th to 10th in the final should get more than the winner of a consolation is basically the work of elitists...it's a consolation...what about the horses that are very talented but were "shortened up", "knocked over" or just had no luck in running at all???? Have the owners of those horses not paid up for the series?? have they not paid up for their training/vet/farrier etc, etc.....people, take a moment, the world is not designed just for your benefit.

    In relation to the horses that were included late,how can you validly claim they have had a "free shot" they have obviously paid their fees to be included in the series, but you people would deny them the chance to get something back??, these horses were not laying around in the paddock, the owners of these horses have incurred similar costs to yours so where do you think they have not earned the right of inclusion????

    Greed is a growing issue in our society, as is elitism.
    Danno, if a horse gets a check in the final and finishes 100m last is APG putting on a consolation for them next week? Bad luck can happen anytime or anywhere. This year I don't think there was any hard luck stories from the semis anyway, they just simply weren't good enough and the field as a whole isn't really worthy of G2 status.
    In the case of Sunshine Hannigan, I have no idea what the planning process was and quite possible it was just by chance she is running this week. But in all likelihood she would be an also run in the final. Why not wait for the consolation where she is a big chance of winning and getting a G2 next to her name. If we're talking elitist, Bernie Kelly and his breed is as elite as they come, a G2 win will just enhance that eliteness whilst the filly who runs fourth in the final gets diddly squat.
    We had a query on the forum just a couple days about a horse possibly not being driven to win. We hate that as an industry. But If you are 20m back running third in a Bathurst heat or sixth in an APG heat why bother trying to qualify for the final. Pull it up and go round in the consolation!

  7. #7
    Senior Member Stallion Danno is a jewel in the rough
    Real Name
    Dan Gibson
    Location
    Hunter Valley NSW Australia
    Occupation
    Driving 175:1 winners!
    Posts
    1,153
    Horses
    No Stars
    Brendan,
    I think if we are going to base our arguements on "this horse and these circumstances" we will forever be running in circles, the issue as I see it is do we have a consolation? how much is it worth? and who is eliglible?
    I have never in my forty years as a licenced person ( got my permit on my sixteenth birthday Feb 1974) seen one solitary instance of a consolation having less prizmoney for the winner than the unplaced runners in the final, mate that sort of mentality is breaking new ground.

    Spare a thought for the not quite so lucky, they have contributed just as much as the fortunate.

    Cheers,
    Dan

  8. #8
    Senior Member Horse Of The Year mightymo will become famous soon enough
    Real Name
    Harvey Kaplan
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    647
    Horses
    Bling It On, Nike Franco, Cruz Bromac
    Lets say you have a nice filly, but not a top one who makes it to the APG semis. Instead of trying to finish in the top 5 and make the final, you are better off letting the horse sit last and finish 6-10th and then be eligible for a 50K race where you are a good chance to win??

    How is that good for the sport??

    This is nothing about elitism - its about common sense.

    Why dont we let all first round losers at wimbledon go into the plate comp and play for prizemoney that is more than the qtr finalists get?? What a load of nonsense!!

  9. #9
    Senior Member 2YO Bonnie will become famous soon enough
    Real Name
    Anne Anderson
    Location
    Melbourne Victoria
    Occupation
    Horse Breeder /Owner
    Posts
    172
    Horses
    Ladies In Red, Hurricane Harley, Honolua
    Quote Originally Posted by Danno View Post
    I'm inclined to disagree with you all,

    Firstly, a consolation race is "exactly" that...had no luck in the heats, heres another chance to earn some $$ for being involved in the series. The arguement that 6th to 10th in the final should get more than the winner of a consolation is basically the work of elitists...it's a consolation...what about the horses that are very talented but were "shortened up", "knocked over" or just had no luck in running at all???? Have the owners of those horses not paid up for the series?? have they not paid up for their training/vet/farrier etc, etc.....people, take a moment, the world is not designed just for your benefit.

    In relation to the horses that were included late,how can you validly claim they have had a "free shot" they have obviously paid their fees to be included in the series, but you people would deny them the chance to get something back??, these horses were not laying around in the paddock, the owners of these horses have incurred similar costs to yours so where do you think they have not earned the right of inclusion????

    Greed is a growing issue in our society, as is elitism.
    It has nothing to do with elitism. If you enter a competition you play by the rules. Heats for the APG Series are held in Victoria, Queensland and New South Wales, giving every eligible horse the opportunity to race in the series. You are even allowed to select the venue that best suits your needs and the race dates are specified in the Sale Catalogue when you purchase or pay up for your yearling over 12 months prior to the heats.
    In Victoria there is a football competition called the AFL , if you don' t play every game you don't play finals. I think you will find that rule applies in most sports.
    You cannot change the rules after the game has started. This destroys the integrity of the completion, sadly something that Harness Racing is striving for.

  10. #10
    Senior Member Horse Of The Year mightymo will become famous soon enough
    Real Name
    Harvey Kaplan
    Location
    Melbourne
    Posts
    647
    Horses
    Bling It On, Nike Franco, Cruz Bromac
    nobody has said lets not have a consolation. i think a consolation is a great idea, but not with Gr 2 status and where the winner of the consolation gets almost as much as the third horse in the main event

+ Reply to Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts