Stewards News 2

[Messenger]

The introduction of AHRR 155A provides that should a horse break gait clear of interference, and remain in the incorrect gait as it passes the finish line, that it mandatorily be placed behind any horse which is covering the horses’ body providing that horse is in its correct gait.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=42363

This should make rulings a bit more cut and dried

[aussiebreno]

The introduction of AHRR 155A provides that should a horse break gait clear of interference, and remain in the incorrect gait as it passes the finish line, that it mandatorily be placed behind any horse which is covering the horses’ body providing that horse is in its correct gait.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=42363

This should make rulings a bit more cut and dried

Absurd ruling.

So breaks anywhere else aren't of the same importance? What does it matter if a horse breaks on the line and actually loses ground. So what. No need to relegate them but they will be relegated in this instance.

A horse neck and neck will be relegated the exact same as a horse nose and rump.

Ok the rule is pretty clear but what happens if you gallop 100m out and get back into stride by the post. Adjudication of finishing position / gained advantage should not be any different just because you broke in a different part of the race.

[Messenger]

I suppose they could simplify it further - if you break without being checked you are disqualified (but then skipping will be a grey area)
I know they disqualify in France - does that include on the line?

[Galli]

I know they disqualify in France - does that include on the line?

Not sure how much the French rules differ (don't think too much, though...) but in Finland it is an automatic disqualification if they gallop or pace over the line. In addition to if they break for more than 150m at the start of the race, more than 100m elsewhere during the race, break more than twice during the race or break anywhere during the last 100m of the race.

[teecee]

Wow!! Is this for real. Australia has adopted one of our rules. Usually the excuse to change our rules is to align with Oz.
It is known here as the "lapped on" rule. It applies to horses who gallop across the finish line in a break when there are other finishers within a length behind.
It only applies to crossing the finish line and provide definitive certainty whether a breaker holds or loses it's placing irrespective of gaining advantage when in a break over the line.
What happens prior to the line is covered by other rules. Ours provides for auto disqualification if a break of more than 50m in final 200m or 150m prior to the final 200.

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=42455

$250 might not sound like much but when you read Trotguide you would have to say he is very stiff

https://nationaltrotguide.com.au/its-no-fine-cotton-scandal/?fbclid=IwAR1t-4I5kg6mI_BO1NXUws-G4DeQiEqXSJJWyEm61HMtsPyynxbEu9iis_c

[Messenger]

Oh Zechariah

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=42884

[aussiebreno]

Not sold on needing a new thread because now have to search 2 threads if wanting to find old info but rest of us can't post in the original Stewards news thread you posted in earlier this arvo Kev. I'd suggest just keep one thread or at least start using this thread.

[Messenger]

Sorry about that Breno - I forgot about the new one
I think it is worth having a new one because when you do a search using the search engine it will tell you what thread to find the key word in but not what page so if a thread is 50 pages long the search engine does not help you that much

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=43016

These charges have been coming for 12 years ? !

[Showgrounds]

And they say justice is swift!

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=PC290220

CODE BAILEY NZ was presented three (3) minutes past the allocated time.

Prior to a scheduled inquiry on Saturday 29 February, HRNSW Stewards were informed that an interim decision had been made that for all horse’s subject of late arrivals in Grand Circuit or Group 1 events, which includes the use of the retention facility in Grand Circuit or Group 1 events, the Chief Executive on notification of the Chief Steward and/or Integrity Manager, will be provided the power of a Steward under Rule 300 and will hold the sole discretionary power to determine the circumstance of the late arrival and to determine if the subject horse(s) are withdrawn due to late arrival.

Some will no doubt say, sense prevailing but I doubt it provides much comfort to the Cross stable who had their horses withdrawn from the Newcastle Mile for being 6 mins late

[Showgrounds]

It wouldn't be a Miracle Mile without rules being and made (and broken) on the run.

[Messenger]

I will be interested in seeing the replay for R2 at Melton tonight if Mediatec ever get it up
because the Stewards were clearly not happy

GS L PH 1 QUER PRB SWAB INQADJ INQADJ

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX050320#KIC05032004

[Showgrounds]

I will be interested in seeing the replay for R2 at Melton tonight if Mediatec ever get it up
because the Stewards were clearly not happy

GS L PH 1 QUER PRB SWAB INQADJ INQADJ

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX050320#KIC05032004

Interesting run that would have kept the stewards on their toes. Also interesting they reckon the winner pulled hard because he was driven hard to lead but then the driver was seen to be getting up the horse from the 1200 metres. Perhaps their binoculars fogged up.

I'm not saying anything, but I'd kill to eat whatever that horse is being fed. It would restore my energy levels to where they should be!

[gutwagon]

Trevor and Kevin, there are rumours that the horse went straight to a rave party after the race and danced until 6 am ! Unconfirmed of course.
I notice the driver had the reins in one hand for the last part of the race also. As for pulling hard, the stewards need to go to speck savers !

[Messenger]

Totally agree about the need for an optometrist appointment - I thought there was only one quarter where he was not urging him on

In the previous month he had had 4 starts where he lobbed in the sit (3) every time but could not run a place
All those runs were over 2100m, maybe he can only run 1700m
Maybe the rain affected track helped his legs?
Maybe the field was that bad?

?????

[Showgrounds]

Hope the stewards checked the brand's!

[Messenger]

VRT decision

http://www.harness.org.au/NEWS/news2/uploads/VRT%20Decision%20Jayden%20Barker%20Appeal%203%20Ma rch%202020.pdf

RIDICULOUS

The kid on the fav gets 5 weeks while the 2 clowns that stitched him up and saw their horsed beaten by 77m and 159m get ZIP

Here is the race

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX090120#MXC09012002

Here is the Stewards Report

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=MX090120

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=43212
It does not read well

It was Gerry Giraffe's one and only start in the last week of last season

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=HS260819#HSC26081907

I see that Robert King is listed as a Grade A trainer on Harnessweb
It must be like getting a license to drive a car, once you get it you keep it forever for I see the above start was Robert King's one and only starter as a trainer for 18-19
He has had none in 19-20, 10 in 17-18, None in 16-17, 5 in 15-16, 15 in 14-15 when he last had a winner

[Showgrounds]

Interesting read. What were they trying to hide? No vet available? No excavator?

The other option would have been to call that knackery. Actually that is no longer an option as, thanks to the ABC awakening the inner animal activist in the general public, knackery operators refuse to take any branded horse. This includes freeze brands.

[Messenger]

It is alleged that Ms Tubbs presented the horse ‘Cash Lover’ to race at Ballarat on 8 January 2020 when not free of the prohibited substance Aminorex.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=43283

Aminorex is an amphetamine-like stimulant drug banned in racing and other equestrian competitions because horses given clinical doses would be hyperactive and may perform better.

https://www.horseandhound.co.uk/horse-care/vet-advice/vets-trace-unexpected-source-of-banned-substance-aminorex-hh-plus-705982

A brassica plant that can be found growing in pastures across the United States can result in horses failing a drug test, research findings suggest

https://www.horsetalk.co.nz/2019/12/26/pasture-weed-positive-drug-tests-some-horses/

I wouldn't think Yellow Rocket could be a factor as it is a Winter weed

The race in question

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA080120#BAC08012009

[gutwagon]

Any suspensions should not start until racing resumes.

All people currently suspended/disqualified must have their sentence extended for whatever time racing is shut down.

[Mytwobobsworth]

Looking forward to hearing the outcome of the stewards inquiry into the trot at Bendigo Thursday just gone.
Rumours of “excessive whip use”.

[Messenger]

Heard that rumour too John and for once it may be that the horse was not the recipient

[Adaptor]

Heard that rumour too John and for once it may be that the horse was not the recipient

RACE 4 – HYGAIN MAIDEN TROT (2150 MS)

The Night King and Singing The Girl contacted marker pegs rounding the final turn.

Arrjays Trapper tired over the concluding stages to be beaten 74m for which a warning was issued.

Stewards opened an inquiry into the conduct of Haydon Gray (Just Oscar) and Derrick Krafft (Singing The Girl) during and following the running of this race. After taking evidence from Mr Gray, Mr Krafft, Gary Donaldson (Angski) and Starter Mr Jason Fino this matter was adjourned to a time and date to be fixed. As a result of the evidence adduced during the inquiry submissions were sought from Mr Gray as to whether the provisions of Rule 183(b) should be invoked. After consideration of the submissions from Mr Gray, Stewards ordered that in accordance with Rule 183(b) he not be permitted to drive in races and trials until the completion of this investigation including pending the final determination of any charges which may be issued by Stewards for determination by the Victorian Racing Tribunal.

As a result of this incident Mr Gray was removed from his remaining drives, Race 6 – Rocknroll Noah (replaced by Anthony Crossland) and Race 7 – Rigondeaux (replaced by Maddie Ray)

[Messenger]

Haydon Gray got 12mths for striking another driver with his whip

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=43709

[Showgrounds]

Haydon Gray got 12mths for striking another driver with his whip

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=43709

The precedent to this incident was Don Dove receiving 12 months disqualification, as opposed to suspension, for swiping Brian Gath across the chest in the home straight at the Showgrounds in the mid-1970's. Dovey was driving the leader and Brian was challenging from the death. Caused a great deal of controversy at the time, Dovey paid dearly for his brain fade.

[Messenger]

Drives like that of Rodney Petroff on Segesta in R3 at Kilmore need a big fine so that they know they have to fill their allocated barrier position, not choose where they want to go
He drew 7 but had no intention of filling that spot and was already angling for the SR2 position

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=KI130520#KIC13052009

[Mytwobobsworth]

Highlight of that replay for me was the work of Brad Chisholm when out of contention to help control the driverless horse and prevent any possible injuries or further drama.

[gutwagon]

Drives like that of Rodney Petroff on Segesta in R3 at Kilmore need a big fine so that they know they have to fill their allocated barrier position, not choose where they want to go
He drew 7 but had no intention of filling that spot and was already angling for the SR2 position

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=KI130520#KIC13052009
With only 8 starters atm and no back row runners horses being out of position at the start has become very common .
It is very common to see the horses drawn 1 and 2 hold back from the mobile and hit the gate at top speed to gain a fast start. They are only in position right at the start point. They only penalty seems to be a warning for OPS.
For integrity reasons this needs to be stamped out. If horses are not in position about 30m before the start, the start should be aborted and large fines placed on drivers. Under the current rules they should be false starts but the starters are ignoring the rules. Most likely due to pressure from Sky Racing to have races start on time.

I believe integrity (Fair starts) are more important for the industry.
Here is a perfect example of what I am talking about. Yes my horses suffered due to it so there are some sour grapes involved. Watch race 5.
https://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA060520

[aussiebreno]

With only 8 starters atm and no back row runners horses being out of position at the start has become very common .
It is very common to see the horses drawn 1 and 2 hold back from the mobile and hit the gate at top speed to gain a fast start. They are only in position right at the start point. They only penalty seems to be a warning for OPS.
For integrity reasons this needs to be stamped out. If horses are not in position about 30m before the start, the start should be aborted and large fines placed on drivers. Under the current rules they should be false starts but the starters are ignoring the rules. Most likely due to pressure from Sky Racing to have races start on time.

I believe integrity (Fair starts) are more important for the industry.
Here is a perfect example of what I am talking about. Yes my horses suffered due to it so there are some sour grapes involved. Watch race 5.
https://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA060520

I endorse this post.

Haven't watched video but its not sour grapes at all - rules are clearly being broken and having an affect on the race and other horses chances. Its downright cheating and the penalties are nowhere near severe enough.

[Messenger]

An interesting one in the Stewards Reports from Bathurst 10/5/20. In the follow up reports for a race at Bathurst on 24/4/20. Trainer fined $100 for an alteration to the lugging pole. Trainer then fined $200 for not adhering to a Stewards instruction to fix the aforesaid lugging pole and using it in the race! If the stewards observed it before the race, why was it not checked again prior to the start, ensuring it had been fixed?

[Messenger]

Firerockfireroll was nearly surprised by Pur Dan in the last at Melton tomorrow but when the replay is up have a look at what was going on with Connor Clarke's left foot in the last bit (hopefully the replay will include the head on)

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX160520D#MXC160520D02

[Messenger]

I have been told that he was just activating some gear. Pur Dan (a real Gavin Lang drive by Ryan Duffy) nearly snuck up on him and definitely somewhat caught him by surprise

[aussiebreno]

I have been told that he was just activating some gear. Pur Dan (a real Gavin Lang drive by Ryan Duffy) nearly snuck up on him and definitely somewhat caught him by surprise

Jnr driver certainly got a learning experience without having to lose the race.

[gutwagon]

Take a look at race 5 Melton last night (16/5/20) . Candy Man tries to get a flying start on the fav from the pole, does his usual hanging back 15m from the gate and tries to hit the gate at high speed just at the start point. Missed timed it this time, hit the gate and horse galloped, ran last.
Stewards take on it - horse began badly, out of draw. Removed the score up from replay and commence replay from start point. No penalty for driver.

Do they think we are idiots ? We just want a level playing field.

[aussiebreno]

Take a look at race 5 Melton last night (16/5/20) . Candy Man tries to get a flying start on the fav from the pole, does his usual hanging back 15m from the gate and tries to hit the gate at high speed just at the start point. Missed timed it this time, hit the gate and horse galloped, ran last.
Stewards take on it - horse began badly, out of draw. Removed the score up from replay and commence replay from start point. No penalty for driver.

Do they think we are idiots ? We just want a level playing field.

+1

[Messenger]

When can a horse leave the course? After All Clear is given?

Interesting to read in the Stewards Report for R3 at Bendigo last Thursday

"Post-race veterinary examination was attempted on Ozzie Playboy however was unsuccessful due to the gelding having left the course."

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=BN210520

[Showgrounds]

HRV Wuhan Flu guidelines make it clear all participants, and I presume this includes horses, are to leave the course as soon as their commitments are over. Either the stewards were asleep or the horse was driven off the track into the float!

[Messenger]

Haydon Gray got 12mths for striking another driver with his whip

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=43709

Gray faced two charges and only received a suspension for one (the other was a fine)
He received 12 months (with the possibility of a 3mth reduction)
It commenced on April 30
Why is the Suspended Driver's list showing and End Date of May 31 - that is only 1 month

[Adaptor]

Evidence from a telephone:

https://www.harness.org.au/NEWS/news2/uploads/Harness%20Stewards%20Inquiry%20%20TrainerDriver%20 Mr%20C.%20Hall.pdf

[Messenger]

This is the race

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=GP240120#GPM24012009

Who did he want Crocodile Kid to hand up to?

[Messenger]

I am not a punter but I wouldn't think it out of place for the stewards to ask Matt Craven why he surrendered the lead in the last at Stawell today - I am not saying that he wouldn't have a VG answer
But we know that Stawell is one hell of a leaders track, that they were not going fast and that most of his horse's wins have been as leader

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SW280520#SWC28052002

[Mighty Atom]

What is wrong with this guy? It is not the first time he has fallen seriously foul of the RWWA stewards.

[Messenger]

Stewards QIP ed Teddy Runkle for his win tonight
Come on!
It was his 2nd EVER start - duh

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA110620#BAC11062004

[Showgrounds]

Stewards QIP ed Teddy Runkle for his win tonight
Come on!
It was his 2nd EVER start - duh

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA110620#BAC11062004

A long held belief of mine is that modern-day stewards are big on compliance but short on horsemanship. Many of them are yet to understand that the pain eminating from their foot is caused by the horse standing on it.

[Showgrounds]

A long held belief of mine is that modern-day stewards are big on compliance but short on horsemanship. Many of them are yet to understand that the pain eminating from their foot is caused by the horse standing on it.

Sad to hear of the passing of Rod Osborne, one of Victoria's greatest ever stewards. He was a trainer/driver before he was a steward and I doubt he ever queried the improved performance of a horse having a second race start.

[Messenger]

A couple of 4 month Disqualifications handed down (although one is already serving 12mths anyway)

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=44020

This was the race at Mildura back in Feb that obviously upset Mr Rogers (Leader) with Ms Phillips (Death)

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ML060220#MLC06022006

Here is the Stewards Report (that does not tell us much)

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=ML060220

I am not sure how Ms Hryhorec got involved

[Messenger]

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=TE180620

Kima Frenning, driver of Beautiful Woman ($1.10 fav) which led the event prior to yielding ground rapidly from the 600m before finished in 9th and last position beaten 167.2m was queried into the poor performance of the filly. Ms Frenning explained Beautiful Woman provided to be extremely disappointing and attribute the performance to a combination of factors when entering the back straight on the first occasion and releasing the hopple shorteners the near side cord became entangled with the hobbles momentarily resulting in the filly racing keenly thereafter and recording a faster than normal lead time of 40.5 seconds (1.7 faster than the average) Ms Frenning advised the filly may be best driven less aggressively at the start of its races as Beautiful Woman had performed in a similar manner when having its first initial start on the 29th April 2020. A post-race veterinary examination of the filly failed to reveal any significant abnormalities Beautiful Woman will now be stood down from racing until trialling to the satisfaction of Stewards on one (1) occasion. Emma Stewart, trainer of Beautiful Woman will be contacted in the coming days relative to the progress of the filly subsequent to the event.


This struck me as very insightful from Kima as even though she did not drive the horse in her first start, there are definitely similarities between the 2 races

It was only the filly's 5th start and even though she had led and won at her previous start they had not gone hard
She had only run some serious time when she was behind the leader over a shorter trip at Melton
In hindsight it would seem that $1.10 were very silly odds against more seasoned horses

[Messenger]

Jess Tubbs does not receive a suspension for Cash Lover winning with Aminorex in its system
Aminorex is an amphetamine-like stimulant drug banned in racing and other equestrian competitions because horses given clinical doses would be hyperactive and may perform better.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=44219

In considering penalty, the VRT accepted the distinct possibility that the presence of aminorex in the sample obtained from ‘Cash Lover’ on 8 January 2020 was a result of the horse ingesting plants from the Brassicaceae family found to be present in the paddock where it was housed prior to the race.

Unfortunately we will have to wait at least a week for the further link to the decision to be up so that we can see why she gets away with this

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/NEWS/news2/uploads/VRT-Decision-Damien-Wilson-Hearing-8-July-2020.pdf

Damien Wilson very lucky to get his 8 weeks reduced to 4 weeks

The VRT fell for a sob story despite stating

You would appreciate that it is not a good look, to put it mildly, for a driver of your talent and
experience to be behaving in this way to a very young driver who is just commencing his
career. General deterrence is an important factor. Drivers, and particularly experienced
drivers, must not behave in this fashion.

Have a look at the replay of the finish and you just see it before they go out of frame - clearly bullying

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SP260420

[Messenger]

Jess Tubbs does not receive a suspension for Cash Lover winning with Aminorex in its system
Aminorex is an amphetamine-like stimulant drug banned in racing and other equestrian competitions because horses given clinical doses would be hyperactive and may perform better.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=44219

In considering penalty, the VRT accepted the distinct possibility that the presence of aminorex in the sample obtained from ‘Cash Lover’ on 8 January 2020 was a result of the horse ingesting plants from the Brassicaceae family found to be present in the paddock where it was housed prior to the race.


The ruling is now up and includes:

You have been in the harness racing industry for most of your life. You and your partner have 135 acres, on which, currently there are 50 horses. You have been employed in the harness racing industry and are currently employed in the greyhound industry at the Meadows as the Racing and Marketing Manager. You have an excellent record, and, as stated very fairly by Mr Anderson on behalf of the Stewards, you have a very good name in the industry.
As stated, we accept that this positive swab came as a great shock to you and we agree completely that you in no way had any intention to cheat. The whole affair was totally accidental, and you have taken positive measures to get rid of the problem.


https://djpr.vic.gov.au/priority-industries-sectors/racing/victorian-racing-tribunal/victorian-racing-tribunal-decisions

Maybe she should have been suspended for working for the dish-lickers :D

[Mytwobobsworth]

http://www.harness.org.au/NEWS/news2/uploads/VRT-Decision-Damien-Wilson-Hearing-8-July-2020.pdf

Damien Wilson very lucky to get his 8 weeks reduced to 4 weeks

The VRT fell for a sob story despite stating

You would appreciate that it is not a good look, to put it mildly, for a driver of your talent and
experience to be behaving in this way to a very young driver who is just commencing his
career. General deterrence is an important factor. Drivers, and particularly experienced
drivers, must not behave in this fashion.

Have a look at the replay of the finish and you just see it before they go out of frame - clearly bullying

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SP260420


Thats a disgrace!
Should be talking months not weeks.
Could not be any worse look for the game, if they weren’t out the back you would be talking months.
From memory one of the ainsworth boys got done for similar thing a year or 2 back. There was contact on that occasion but from memory he got 3 or 6 months.

[Messenger]

$102 pop Tiseh Lady beats $3 fav Surfs Up at Kilmore back on Jan 16
We now have TL disqualified due to Arsenic and SU declared the winner

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=44344

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=KI160120#KIC16012004

Joe Farrugia has only be effectively fined $500

There was more than that outlayed on the fav Surfs Up which punters never collected - where is the justice in that?

[Messenger]

The ruling is now up and includes:

You have been in the harness racing industry for most of your life. You and your partner have 135 acres, on which, currently there are 50 horses. You have been employed in the harness racing industry and are currently employed in the greyhound industry at the Meadows as the Racing and Marketing Manager. You have an excellent record, and, as stated very fairly by Mr Anderson on behalf of the Stewards, you have a very good name in the industry.
As stated, we accept that this positive swab came as a great shock to you and we agree completely that you in no way had any intention to cheat. The whole affair was totally accidental, and you have taken positive measures to get rid of the problem.


https://djpr.vic.gov.au/priority-industries-sectors/racing/victorian-racing-tribunal/victorian-racing-tribunal-decisions

Maybe she should have been suspended for working for the dish-lickers :D

Tassie are suggesting that they might no be so understanding

"Trainers are put on notice that environmental contamination (through ingestion of plants) will not
necessarily be considered a significant penalty mitigating factor for presentation of a horse with Aminorex in
a sample in the future. "

https://www.harness.org.au/NEWS/news2/uploads/ATTENTION%20TRAINERS%20-%20Industry%20notice%20regarding%20Aminorex%20-%2022-07-2020.pdf

[Messenger]

Brad Chisholm chose to let No 12 Kyvalley Barney score up in a 3rd line posn in the R2 trot instead of outside the 2nd line
It cannot be allowed - we need heavy fines or suspensions for this

[gutwagon]

Kevin, my question is why did the starter allow Kyvalley Barney to score up out of position ? It should be a false start, why do they constantly fail at their job? Many drivers now know they will be allowed to start out of position and are happy to take the fine !

Lochinvar Art also started out of position to ensure he didn't get boxed in.


It should be a false start and a big fine to the driver. If they fail to take their position the second time the horse is scratched and driver finned and or suspended.

[Messenger]

Pending VRT Hearing - Nathan Jack, Mark Pitt, Russell Jack & Tammy Gibbons

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=44540

A couple of notorious names there that have trouble abiding by the rules

[Showgrounds]

Pending VRT Hearing - Nathan Jack, Mark Pitt, Russell Jack & Tammy Gibbons

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=44540

A couple of notorious names there that have trouble abiding by the rules

It's like a virus to these people, without the lockdown!

[Messenger]

Or

These people are like a virus and we don't have sufficient lockdown measures

[Messenger]

CARBINE CHEMICALS - NOTICE ISSUED BY APVMA TO STOP SUPPLY

http://www.harness.org.au/NEWS/news2/uploads/200812%20CARBINE%20CHEMICALS%20-%20NOTICE%20ISSUED%20BY%20APVMA%20TO%20STOP%20SUPP LY.pdf

Interesting if you do a google search for Carbine Chemicals
You will see ads/prices for some of their products that are mentioned as NO NO's in the above link

[Messenger]

You can see why Michelle Phillips got a QDT & Warning Issued for her drive on I Am Marquez, if you didn't know any better you would think she had the job of working the fav in the lead
Maybe it was decided that Amanda Turnbull's run of long odds on faves had to come to an end (Sorry Anne)

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BN120820#BNC12082003

Finishing 70m off the winner and 68m off the one she pressured - we will have to await the Stewards Report to see why she was not suspended

[Bonnie]

You can see why Michelle Phillips got a QDT & Warning Issued for her drive on I Am Marquez, if you didn't know any better you would think she had the job of working the fav in the lead
Maybe it was decided that Amanda Turnbull's run of long odds on faves had to come to an end (Sorry Anne)

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BN120820#BNC12082003


Finishing 70m off the winner and 68m off the one she pressured - we will have to await the Stewards Report to see why she was not suspended

I am glad you posted this Kev as I wear rose coloured glasses when my horses go round. I think Michelle Phillips should have been suspended.. She stirred I Am Marquez up, contested the lead twice and was gone on the turn into the straight. No doubt will blame the horse for pulling!!. The caller said ‘ no surprise ‘ when her horse dropped out and Be My Baby was ‘ hammered in front ‘ . Much tougher penalties are required to stamp out this style of driving. It’s not a good look when a $1.30 favourite is beaten , finishing third and the other horse finishes last beaten 70 metres. HRV will loose their greatest assets THEIR OWNERS if steps are not taken to protect our horses and ensure a fair run , win loose or draw.

[Messenger]

You can see why Michelle Phillips got a QDT & Warning Issued for her drive on I Am Marquez, if you didn't know any better you would think she had the job of working the fav in the lead
Maybe it was decided that Amanda Turnbull's run of long odds on faves had to come to an end (Sorry Anne)

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BN120820#BNC12082003

Finishing 70m off the winner and 68m off the one she pressured - we will have to await the Stewards Report to see why she was not suspended

RACE 8 – J & A MAZZETTI PAINTING PACE (2ND HEAT) (2150 MS)

Driver Brad Chisholm (Warraderry) was cautioned for his whip use outside the confines of the sulky early in the home straight.

Stewards inquired into the driving tactics adopted by Michelle Phillips (I Am Marquez). Ms Phillips explained that whilst the gelding was first up from a five week let up trainer C Latter had advised her that the gelding had worked well in the lead up to the race and was capable of a forward showing. Ms Phillips explained that she had allowed her drive to trail Rockon Locksley forward around the first turn and when that runner obtained a position in the one out line she then briefly drove her horse forward at which point she believed the leader had eased the pace of the race and her momentum from driving I Am Marquez forward saw her race up on level terms, then slightly in advance of Be My Baby in the back straight before she then restrained her drive. She then further explained that driver Amanda Turnbull (Be My Baby) when racing off the back straight on the first occasion then attempted to restrain that runner to the extent that that left her drive I Am Marquez heading that runner and for this reason she issued brief challenge for the lead before immediately ceasing when it became apparent that the lead was not available.. Ms Phillips further explained and Stewards verified on the replays that her horse had then travelled strongly outside the leader before then coming under pressure from the 500m. A post-race veterinary examination revealed no apparent abnormalities. In assessing the matter stewards took into consideration Ms Phillips’ explanation, their own observations, sectional times for the race, the official race replays and also the recent race reformances of I Am Marquez and were of the view that the horse had performed tonight significantly below its recent demonstrated capabilities and for this reason no action was taken against driver Michelle Phillips licence. A warning has been paced upon the gelding for tiring. Stewards will follow up with trainer Col Latter in the days subsequent to the event.

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=BN120820

I still think the driver should have received a warning, not just the horse!

[aussiebreno]

Jack Laugher on The Defiant Rc2 Melton. Spew

[Messenger]

The Stewards Report for Saturday's Shep meet finally out this evening
Very brief
One sentence for R2 and R9
No questioning of Glenn Douglas's or Chris Alford's drives

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=SP150820

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SP150820

[Messenger]

The Stewards Report for Saturday's Shep meet finally out this evening
Very brief
One sentence for R2 and R9
No questioning of Glenn Douglas's or Chris Alford's drives

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=SP150820

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SP150820

Anybody else think that Glenn Douglas did not seem interested in 3rd or 4th in R2
Or that Chris Alford buried the co-fav in R9?
I am happy for people to disagree, I don't want to push it if others think I am imagining things

pm Me if you like

[Messenger]

QIP for Saint Calder, winner at Ballarat today
A 3yo trotter, he had only had 2 starts before today and that was 10 months ago
He has a new trainer
What is the new trainer going to say to the QIP - "he's always gone alright for me"

[Messenger]

Joe Bajada Total Penalty: 3 years disqualification and $6350 fine

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=44903

[Messenger]

Ridiculous warning issued in the 2yo race 1 at Horsham today
The last 2 horses have been warned for tiring. They are 2yo's who still broke 2 minutes
Without them accepting we probably don't have a race
They were not in the betting
Give the owners a break - if a hard nosed steward does the same again to them next start, then they probably get stood down = less horses = less races

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=HS170920#HSC17092007

[Messenger]

I just watched the above race again. Interesting protest decision - the first past the post definitely interfered with second but I am not sure that Jacks Hawk was ever going to let Keayang Kamikaze beat him

[Messenger]

From the Echuca Stewards Report

Licensed driver Daryl Douglas was found guilty of a charge under Rule 231(2) which reads: A person shall not misconduct himself in any way. The particulars of the charge being that Mr Douglas gestured inappropriately whilst leaning out of a moving vehicle to a member of the public as he was arriving at the racecourse. Mr Douglas offered no plea to the charge. Mr Douglas was fined $500. In assessing penalty stewards were mindful of the HRV Minimum Penalty Guidelines and the nature of the offence having misconducted himself towards a member of the public.

Stewards intend to inquire into the conduct of trainer Glenn Douglas and driver Daryl Douglas shortly after arriving on-course.

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=EC200920

[Showgrounds]

Well, that didn't take long.

[Messenger]

I just watched the above race again. Interesting protest decision - the first past the post definitely interfered with second but I am not sure that Jacks Hawk was ever going to let Keayang Kamikaze beat him

Going on that win at Melton just now, Jack was never going to let anything past him

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX260920#MXM26092006

[Showgrounds]

The stewards report for Saturday night's Melton meeting is now up on the HRA website. Naturally, I went straight to the Smoken Up Sprint to get the stewards take on the greatest race day flop of the year, Ride High.

Noticeably, no swab was taken from the horse! Somebody is asleep at the wheel at HRV with such a basic procedure being confined to the too hard basket. This, and the rent-a-quote reporting being fed through a compliant (should that be subservient?) media, would indicate HRV is content to treat the public as mugs.

An unbackable favourite, effortless winner of it previous eleven starts by huge margins in clock-shattering times has flopped in a huge way. And officials do not see a reason to take a routine swab!

"Move along, nothing to see here!"

[Njcstables]

The stewards report for Saturday night's Melton meeting is now up on the HRA website. Naturally, I went straight to the Smoken Up Sprint to get the stewards take on the greatest race day flop of the year, Ride High.

Noticeably, no swab was taken from the horse! Somebody is asleep at the wheel at HRV with such a basic procedure being confined to the too hard basket. This, and the rent-a-quote reporting being fed through a compliant (should that be subservient?) media, would indicate HRV is content to treat the public as mugs.

An unbackable favourite, effortless winner of it previous eleven starts by huge margins in clock-shattering times has flopped in a huge way. And officials do not see a reason to take a routine swab!

"Move along, nothing to see here!"

Trevor a post race swab was done as was a post race blood test.

[Showgrounds]

Trevor a post race swab was done as was a post race blood test.

My mistake, I should have gone to the bottom of the report instead of just the race. Where does it say in the report about the blood test? Cannot find it mentioned.

[Messenger]

My mistake, I should have gone to the bottom of the report instead of just the race. Where does it say in the report about the blood test? Cannot find it mentioned.

With Nathan's connections he would know

[gutwagon]

My mistake, I should have gone to the bottom of the report instead of just the race. Where does it say in the report about the blood test? Cannot find it mentioned.
The stewards report doesn't list the blood test but the stewards comments in the results does mention swab and blood test . The stewards really need to get this stuff right for integrity reasons. The public really can't be sure what happened !

[Showgrounds]

The stewards report doesn't list the blood test but the stewards comments in the results does mention swab and blood test . The stewards really need to get this stuff right for integrity reasons. The public really can't be sure what happened !

And I notice no mention of betting fluctuations. Perhaps the stewards assume that an empty betting ring means there was no betting activity.

Ever heard of Betfair? Check the activity on the race there.

[Messenger]

From R1 at Melton last night, looking at the expression on the face of Tayla French mid race - driver of leader Form Analyst, one might believe she is thinking that John Justice in the death is softening her up for brother Lance on her back

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX101020#MXM10102011

Then in R3 was it really 'magic' by Greg Sugars to get Abouttime off the fence or had he already discussed with Anthony Butt whether Manthadee wanted the fence. Why else would Butt be easing then. I would love to see the side on of when he comes out as at the post they were still level and it would have constituted dangerous driving if you didn't know the other horse was easing for the fence

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX101020#MXM10102005

[Messenger]

John Nicholson gets a QDT for deciding he is going to lead on the favourite as opposed to letting the 2nd fav have it? Really

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=KI141020#KIC14102007

[Mytwobobsworth]

John Nicholson gets a QDT for deciding he is going to lead on the favourite as opposed to letting the 2nd fav have it? Really

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=KI141020#KIC14102007


Had gone back last couple of starts, today leads from wide.

[Messenger]

If COT still exists that is fair enough (I thought they had done away with COT)

[aussiebreno]

If COT still exists that is fair enough (I thought they had done away with COT)
Not specific to this horse but just because you don't have to tell stewards about a change in tactics doesn't mean crooked shit goes unchecked. A horse thats gone back repeatedly and gets plunged and then leads is QDT for sure. Likewise a horse that usually goes forward that goes back and runs dead is a QDT for sure. Not having to tell stewards beforehand doesn't mean dodgy tactics go unchecked.

[Messenger]

I can see that a scenario such as you describe "A horse thats gone back repeatedly and gets plunged and then leads" may be grounds for a retrospective inquiry into its previous starts (although the answer may often be - we didn't think it could get the lead that race)
I'm just not sure you can QDT, query the driving tactic of getting the lead and winning - clearly good successful tactics. I would probably go for QIP before QDT

[Messenger]

What about the QIP for Image of Starzzz winning R4 at Terang tonight
He led and rated 1.58.6 to win
At his previous start he only got beaten 6m when the winner went 1.53.9
It is not his fault that he started $50 because the race included one top line 2yo who was having his 2nd start back after 15mths off and one heavily supported runner next to him who began badly

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=TE141020#TEC14102001

[aussiebreno]

I can see that a scenario such as you describe "A horse thats gone back repeatedly and gets plunged and then leads" may be grounds for a retrospective inquiry into its previous starts (although the answer may often be - we didn't think it could get the lead that race)
I'm just not sure you can QDT, query the driving tactic of getting the lead and winning - clearly good successful tactics. I would probably go for QIP before QDT

Horse going back from gate 4 flying home 3 and 4 wide in 1.58 was same performance as next start when it leads from 4 and wins in 1.57. Its the drive that is different.

[Messenger]

In R5 Melton tonight, why did Scott Ewen let Kate Gath on the eq fav Out To Play, off the fence, he clearly looks at her before letting her out
He paid for it too as I reckon Bulletproof Boy could have gone close from the 1x1

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX171020#MXM17102001

[Messenger]

Some are reporting that this may not be the only case under investigation re EPO

NSW - Trainer Stood Down - Mr Malcolm Locke

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=45358

[Showgrounds]

Some are reporting that this may not be the only case under investigation re EPO

NSW - Trainer Stood Down - Mr Malcolm Locke

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=45358

I believe the are more than a couple of dozen B samples that are no longer gathering dust and are ready to serve active duty. Watch this space.

[Messenger]

Brett Day is back as Chairman of Stewards at HRV
He left late August for a position with Greyhounds NSW in part to be closer to family
But is now back due to specialist medical treatment a family member can only receive in Melbourne

[Messenger]

Some are reporting that this may not be the only case under investigation re EPO

NSW - Trainer Stood Down - Mr Malcolm Locke

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=45358

Mr Locke appears on this TCO2 list too

I am thinking that some old samples must be getting retested as only 2 on the list are recent

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=45478

[Adaptor]

Noticed on the Integrity Matters part of TheTrots.com that former Head Steward Bterr Day is returning from NSW and retired veteran Barry Delaney will work part time.

[Messenger]

Yes, I put a little detail to the Day story in Post 93

[Messenger]

All states need something clear cut like they have in Tassie

https://dpipwe.tas.gov.au/racing/stewards-inquiries-decisions

[Messenger]

HRNSW Integrity staff and contracted security conducted security measures at the registered Stable address of Mr Craig Cross;

Ø Thursday 8th October 2020, Friday 9th October 2020 & Saturday 10th October 2020.

Ø Thursday 15th October 2020, Friday 16th October 2020 & Saturday 17th October 2020.

Ø Thursday 22nd October 2020, Friday 23rd October 2020 & Saturday 24th October 2020.

Ø Thursday 29th October 2020, Friday 30th October 2020 & Saturday 31st October 2020.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=45634

This would appear to be pretty concentrated attention

[Showgrounds]

Refer to post #91 and I reckon you will find the stewards' newly found enthusiasm.

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=46037

Oh Mr Jack and the girlfriend
Mr Jack wore it last time for the couple but I can't see Amanda Turnbull getting away unscathed from this one - would seem to show little respect for the industry

Mr Loch now in control in SA

[Showgrounds]

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=46037

Oh Mr Jack and the girlfriend
Mr Jack wore it last time for the couple but I can't see Amanda Turnbull getting away unscathed from this one - would seem to show little respect for the industry

Mr Loch now in control in SA

Apparently several buckets of iced water thrown at HRSA officials alerted them to this widely known fact. Perhaps a well directed melting iceberg aimed at Victorian officials might get them to check out the Victorian stable.

[Messenger]

As an aside, I would like to know why it is so hard to find the link to this story on harness.org.au ?
If I had not been sent it by a poster I would never have found it
I make a habit of looking at HRA's News tab and clicking on Top Stories and Stewards (Wrap) but you won't find it under either of those ??!!
Without being given the link, the only way I can find it is to go to News Archive but make sure you choose All for the category or Stewards Wrap
Unbelievable that an Archive search of Stewards Wrap will find it but you will not find it by going directly to Stewards Wrap !

[Showgrounds]

As an aside, I would like to know why it is so hard to find the link to this story on harness.org.au ?
If I had not been sent it by a poster I would never have found it
I make a habit of looking at HRA's News tab and clicking on Top Stories and Stewards (Wrap) but you won't find it under either of those ??!!
Without being given the link, the only way I can find it is to go to News Archive but make sure you choose All for the category or Stewards Wrap
Unbelievable that an Archive search of Stewards Wrap will find it but you will not find it by going directly to Stewards Wrap !

Move along, nothing to see here! The HRA motto.

Interesting to note Amanda trained and drove a treble at Parkes yesterday. Love to see her "organisation structure", is who is working and feeding what and when, for Victorian and NSW based horses. We know who the SA "foreman" is. Amanda is playing us all for mugs.

[Messenger]

Sometimes it would be good to have some overhead drone video eg R6 at Melton tonight - it would be interesting to see what caused Jamieson Steele to lock wheels in the home straight
(I am not sure what is happening with the Results page on HRV tonight - R1 has finally gone up and it is the only one so far)

[Messenger]

A couple of posters have pointed out to me that the stewards have been very busy on Tuesdays of late
Before the Vicbred Semis at Melton on the 22nd and before the Silver Consolations at Bendigo on the 29th the stewards have been doing PMS's = Pre Meeting Swabs
First of all they did the Ballarat region for the semis and then the Bendigo/Kilmore region for the Silvers

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX221220

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BN291220

[Messenger]

It is a bit hard to find Stewards Reports in Vic nowadays
They're somewhat hidden
You have to go to Integrity Matters at the bottom of the Vic homepage
and then you have to go to the bottom of Integrity Matters

[Messenger]

Waiting to see if an ADJ INQ goes up for Anthony Butt/Alpine Stride in the Stewards Comments column (if they go up tonight!)

(Mister Wickham deserved better)

[Messenger]

It is there

PRS GS 3WE UCL OLM 2 TIRE QDT VXAR SCOPE INQADJ

They would suspend a junior driver in a heartbeat, I think it should be worse for a leading driver but I am betting he gets off

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX300121#MXM30012101

[Messenger]

Anthony Butt gets 4 weeks but it does not start until midnight Saturday

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=MX300121

Some of it:

(3) As a result of the tactics he adopted it contributed to the race being run at a speed up until the 1200m which was 7.06 seconds faster than the five-year average for races conducted at this track and contributed to Alpine Stride being placed under pressure approaching the 800m and tiring badly to finish in last placing beaten 141.7m.

Mr Butt pleaded not guilty to the charge as issued and requested an adjournment to allow him to present further evidence. Stewards granted the adjournment and ordered that the inquiry reconvene at 1.00 pm on Monday, 1 February 2021.

At the reconvening of the inquiry, Mr Butt produced a report from stable veterinarian Dr Virginia Brosnan advising that Alpine Stride was found to be displaying colitis on 31 January 2021 and 1 February 2021. Evidence was taken from HRV Veterinary Consultant Dr Richard Cust who advised when examined post-race Alpine Stride was not displaying any signs of colitis or any related condition.

Dr Richard Cust 1 v Dr Virginia Brosnan 0

[Messenger]

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-nathan-jack-mark-pitt-russell-jack-tammy-gibbons/

Some will never believe the rules apply to them

[Showgrounds]

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-nathan-jack-mark-pitt-russell-jack-tammy-gibbons/

Some will never believe the rules apply to them

Fifty lashes with a wet Maccas' lettuce leaf. An absolute joke and Russell Jack got off very light. Can't recall any reports of the raid at the time. If not, why not?

Never mind, this is just the prelude to the SA shenanigans is yet to play out. Would N Jack be dumb enough to run the "I didn't know" defence? Perhaps then blunt-brained SA stewards would fall for that.

Whatever, the trots has zero credibility when it talks integrity while these grubs continue to thumb their noses at authority.

[Messenger]

Graham Loch has been acting SA Chairman of Stewards for a while now, so I think they are pretty 'sharp'

[Messenger]

They are not mucking around in America (this all stems from a couple of years back when the FBI got involved)

A racehorse dope dealer who pleaded guilty to running a years-long performance-enhancing drug distribution outfit was sentenced to 18 months in federal prison Tuesday.

Scott Robinson, 48, of Tampa, Florida, will also have to turn over more than $3 million and face three years of supervised release as part of his punishment for the distribution ring, the US Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York said

https://nypost.com/2021/03/09/racehorse-dope-dealer-sentenced-to-18-months-in-prison/

And this is from The Meadowlands Media Relations Department

Management at The Meadowlands has become aware that Rene Allard is training a stable of horses in South Florida. As a result, The Meadowlands, Tioga Downs and Vernon Downs will exclude any horse being trained or that has been trained in that stable in any stake and is actively investigating who owns the horses that are or have been in his stable this winter.

Those owners who currently have or have had horses in Allard’s stable this winter are advised that all horses owned wholly or in part by them will be excluded from participation in all the races at The Meadowlands, Tioga Downs and Vernon Downs and that all of horses owned wholly or in part by them will be deemed ineligible to for any/all administered stakes races at The Meadowlands, Tioga Downs and Vernon Downs for a minimum of three years.

If owners affected by the above are a minority partner on horses with owners that are not affected by the above and are being trained by accepted trainers, they must legitimately divest their interest in those horses, which will be required and demonstrated to the satisfaction of The Meadowlands before the March 15 stakes payments will be accepted on those horses.

The affected owners should notify their partners on the horses that fall into the above category immediately.

“This news is particularly disturbing after the indictments of March and a later superseding charge in December of last year,” said Jeff Gural, president of The Meadowlands. “We, along with the Jockey Club, spent much time and money employing the Five Stones investigators to prepare a case to get the Feds interested which led to all of those indictments. We will continue to partner with the Jockey Club to fund the continuing investigation by Five Stones. We could use support in this initiative and welcome anyone who would like to aid in the funding of this necessary and important endeavor.

“To learn that people actually give this guy horses to train after what was discovered by the Federal investigation boggles the mind. The only reason to do this, that I do this, is to clean up racing so we might have a future and to protect the guys that do try to follow the rules.

“Horsemen seem to have this absurd unspoken bond that they protect each other. Well let me be perfectly clear, trainers that break the rules and use Performance Enhancing Drugs (PEDs) are stealing from you, not me. They are beating your horse with a PED enhanced horse then, they are buying or claiming your horse and them beating you with your own horse. I just don’t get it.”


The beauty of privately owned tracks being able to say - we don't want your horses

[Messenger]

Imagine if Jeff Gural owned Mildura

[Messenger]

I will be interested to see what the protest was against Bulleys Delight, the winner of the Tasmania Cup
Was it the stewards for Rhys Nicholson's dropped foot or his whip action - he deserved to lose it

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=EH130321#EHM13032110

[Showgrounds]

I don't know how many weeks Rhys Nicholson was suspended for but, from my half-century's experience, it won't have been enough.

Took out the favourite at the start when his horse appeared to be steered into it at a 45 degree angle. Then, with the leader mysteriously drifting up the track, he swept towards the lead wildly throwing his reigns at the horse and pole-axed Triple Eight in the process. He clearly did not have control of his horse. From there, he appears to have made a complete mockery of the whip rules, throwing the kitchen sink at the horse to the finish. Once in the straight he dropped his right leg from the cart and appears to make contact with the horse's right rear leg several times. In other words, he was kicking it.

Aware he was low on gas, he then allowed his horse to run at least four cart widths up the track taking the second and third placed horses with him. You can clearly see this in the head on replay on the Tas racing website.

The race caller, Blind Freddy, seems oblivious to all of this which just adds to the farce. Whoever the stewards were in charge last night may have been patting their guide dogs while the race was being run.

Their needs to be an independent inquiry into all aspects of this race. Talk is cheap and all the talk is about integrity. Anybody who disagrees that this disgraceful exhibition is not detrimental to the image of the sport - or what is left of it - needs to pull out a dictionary and look up the meaning of integrity.

Rhys Nicholson deserves a very heavy suspension for the multiple instances of interference and other blatant rule breaches he committed. Unfortunately, I doubt he will get it. Well done son, you've just won Tasmania's premier race by using whatever tactics necessary. Here's your trophy, go and celebrate.

[Showgrounds]

It didn't take long. Tasmanian stewards this afternoon announced it will be conducting an inquiry into race 7 (the Tasmanian Cup) to consider invoking rule AHHR 174(1) with the connections of Bullys Delight, the winner, to attend.

This rule relates to Disqualification and Horse Related Matters. I cannot recall this rule being invoked before, certainly not for a race as high profile as this one.

I'll cut the Tas stewards some slack here because it would have been impossible to dig out and invoke this rule in between races last night. It does signify they mean business and I cannot see how Bullys Delight keeps the race given what I outlined in the previous thread. And Rhys Nicholson might be seeking a new vocation.

See punters.com.au/news for a more in depth story, Chief Steward Steven Shinn is heavily quoted and explains the decision.

[Messenger]

The Stewards Report

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=EH130321

Additionally, although Stewards were able to confirm that Mr Nicholson had indeed ‘hocked’ BULLYS DELIGHT numerous times in the home straight as well as utilising his whip on numerous occasions outside the requirement of the rules, Stewards could not be comfortably satisfied that had this not occurred the placings would have changed. At a subsequent inquiry, Mr Nicholson pleaded guilty to a charge issued under the provisions of AHRR168(1)(e) – improper driving, in that in the home straight on the final occasion, Mr Nicholson dropped his right foot from the sulky stirrup and deliberately made contact with the hind leg of BULLYS DELIGHT (hocking) on numerous occasions. Stewards fined Mr Nicholson $2000 and in addition suspended his driver’s licence for a period to commence midnight 13th of March 2021 and expire midnight 20 March 2021. Additionally, Mr Nicholson pleaded guilty to a charge issued under AHRR156(2)(a), in that in the home straight on the final occasion, he utilised his whip with more than a wrist only flicking motion whilst engaging force from his elbow and shoulder as well as failing to maintain a rein in each hand. Mr Nicholson was fined $1000 and his driver’s licence was suspended for a period to commence midnight the 28th of March 2021 and expire midnight the 25th of April 2021 these suspensions being cumulative. In determining penalty, Stewards took into account the infractions occurred in the LADBROKES TASMANIA CUP as well as Mr Nicholson’s blatant disregard for the rules in both instances. All parties were informed at the conclusion of the protest hearing that Stewards would be conducting an inquiry into whether AHRR174(1) should be invoked.

[Messenger]

If this appeal had been heard last week, it might have saved a bit of embarrassment

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-appeal-rhys-nicholson/

The VRT imposed a 4-month suspension of Mr Nicholson’s drivers licence

[Showgrounds]

If this appeal had been heard last week, it might have saved a bit of embarrassment

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-appeal-rhys-nicholson/

The VRT imposed a 4-month suspension of Mr Nicholson’s drivers licence

The karma bus has many wheels.

[Messenger]

Following on top of the above
Check out the whip actions in the Echuca Cup tonight - yeah they're just using a flicking action :rolleyes:

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=EC190321#ECC19032101

It seem the bigger the race , the more the rules are ignored.

Stewards either have to inform participants that from now on - demotion is a real possibility
Or we ban the whip (only carried for horse management)
Or we stop pretending

And don't tell me the horses don't feel it - or why would the drivers being doing it with such force

[Showgrounds]

Just enforce more serious rule (as per Rhys Nicholson) and disqualify the horses. Tough, but would get rid of the problem.

[Messenger]

The quinella drivers suspended - we await stewards report for details

[Showgrounds]

The quinella drivers suspended - we await stewards report for details

Which demonstrates that both drivers deliberately flaunted the rules to manipulate the race result. Both should be disqualified. Neither Aiken or Sutton can claim to be unaware of what they were they were doing.

[Messenger]

And you had to feel for Daryl Douglas to some extent as even though he could have got a warning he was definitely mindful of the whip rule but could see those either side of him flaunting it. This is demonstrated by his winning drive in the Trotters Cup/Bucket where he needed to make ground but observed the whip rule

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=EC190321#ECC19032109

The Hargreaves/Ashwood protest against him was frivolous as all he did was clip a couple of pegs

ps A half decent drive on the 3rd horse in the trot, should have seen it win

[Messenger]

A total contrast to Aiken's drive on $1.40 Honolua Bay at Melton tonight
I know he had done it hard early but I am not sure he used the whip in the finish, he knew the winner had him but he certainly didn't show any of last night's vigour to try and hold second
The owner would not be complaining, the problem with whips is that people expect you to use them

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX200321#MXM20032102

[Messenger]

The quinella drivers suspended - we await stewards report for details

Stewards inquired into the whip use of driver Josh Aiken (Malcolms Rhythm). Mr Aiken pleaded guilty to a charge pursuant to Rule 156(2)(a). In determining penalty stewards considered Mr Aiken’s recent record under the rule, the severity of the breach, the HRV Minimum Penalty Guidelines and the Group 3 status of the event. Mr Aiken’s licence to drive in races was suspended for 2 weeks, to commence at midnight on 20/3/2021. In addition, a $400 fine was also imposed.

Stewards inquired into the whip use of driver Leigh Sutton (Like A Wildfire NZ). Mr Sutton was fined $200 pursuant to Rule 156(3) for exceeding the maximum permitted number of whip strikes and he also pleaded guilty to a charge pursuant to Rule 156(2)(a) for his whip action which was more than a wrist only flicking motion. In determining penalty Stewards considered the status of the race and Mr Sutton’s recent record under the rule. Mr Sutton’s licence to drive in races was suspended for a period of 2 weeks with a commencement date to be advised.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=EC190321

[Adaptor]

Was it the tight track, or was it careless or over-enthusiastic drivers?
The stewards were certainly kept busy at the Echuca Cup meeting last Friday night. 14 weeks worth of suspensions. 4 suspensions (see above) were for whip mis-use.

Suspensions:

Race 1 R Rolfe R163(1)(a)(iii) 2 weeks

Race 2 L Crossland R156(3) 7 days

Race 2 P Weidenbach R156(2)(a) 2 weeks

Race 3 D Jack R163(1)(a)(iii) 2 weeks

Race 4 T French R163(1)(a)(iii) 7 days

Race 7 A Mifsud R163(1)(a)(iii) 7 days

Race 8 J Aiken R156(2)(a) 2 weeks

Race 8 L Sutton R156(2)(a) 2 weeks

[Messenger]

The whip rule is not having the desired effect.
It is a simple fix - DOUBLE the penalties
A bit like when the AFL went from 15m to 50m penalties and just about stopped the transgressions overnight

[Messenger]

Stewards inquired into the whip use of driver Josh Aiken (Malcolms Rhythm). Mr Aiken pleaded guilty to a charge pursuant to Rule 156(2)(a). In determining penalty stewards considered Mr Aiken’s recent record under the rule, the severity of the breach, the HRV Minimum Penalty Guidelines and the Group 3 status of the event. Mr Aiken’s licence to drive in races was suspended for 2 weeks, to commence at midnight on 20/3/2021. In addition, a $400 fine was also imposed.

Stewards inquired into the whip use of driver Leigh Sutton (Like A Wildfire NZ). Mr Sutton was fined $200 pursuant to Rule 156(3) for exceeding the maximum permitted number of whip strikes and he also pleaded guilty to a charge pursuant to Rule 156(2)(a) for his whip action which was more than a wrist only flicking motion. In determining penalty Stewards considered the status of the race and Mr Sutton’s recent record under the rule. Mr Sutton’s licence to drive in races was suspended for a period of 2 weeks with a commencement date to be advised.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=EC190321

Sutton must have appealed as he is still down to drive on Thursday at Shep and is not on the Suspended drivers list whereas Aiken has begun his suspension
This is not good enough IMO. There needs to be something like the AFL system where if you contest your suspension you risk an extra week on your penalty

[Showgrounds]

Disqualification of the horses they drive is the only way I believe. That or do away with whips altogether.

My stance has hardened considerably since the reprehensible actions in the Tasmanian Championship and previous penalties against that winning driver.

[Adaptor]

26 March 2021 - Ms Amanda Turnbull – HRNSW Stewards have commenced an investigation in relation to a report from the Australian Racing Forensic Laboratory (ARFL) that Triamcinolone Acetonide had been detected in the pre-race blood sample taken from WHOS MY MOTHER NZ prior to it running in race 3, the CORDINA FOOD CO NSW OAKS HEAT 1 (2400 metres) conducted at Menangle on Saturday 20 February 2021. The “B” sample has been confirmed by Racing Analytical Services LTD (RASL) in Victoria. The investigation is continuing.

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=47657

Others listed: Morris, Wade, Hewitt, Russo

[DRUIDRACING]

take 2.... 15/2/18 Amanda Turnbull

[Messenger]

take 2.... 15/2/18 Amanda Turnbull

From 2018

The tribunal found that Turnbull wasn’t blameless in the incident but seemed to indicate that a fine would have been a more appropriate penalty.

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/racing/turnbull-positive-swab-decision-could-promote-suspension-rethink-20180317-p4z4ty.html

So you would think that she is not going to have much to worry about this time either

This was the 2017 race that it related to

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=DU151117#DUC15111709

[Showgrounds]

From 2018

The tribunal found that Turnbull wasn’t blameless in the incident but seemed to indicate that a fine would have been a more appropriate penalty.

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/racing/turnbull-positive-swab-decision-could-promote-suspension-rethink-20180317-p4z4ty.html

So you would think that she is not going to have much to worry about this time either

This was the 2017 race that it related to

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=DU151117#DUC15111709

So, she has not learnt a thing has she. Still having her horses injected, by her vet (or others), with corto steroids under the assumption that it is only illegal if you get caught.

How does she keep getting away with it? I was not aware of the 2018 inquiry. I am aware that she miraculously had charges against her dropped while boyfriend Nathan Jack, Mark Pitt and Lisa Bartley were found guilty of race fixing in the Shepparton Magistrates Court for their misdeeds in the infamous Airbornemagic race at Cobram. And I am painfully aware that she entrusted her horses to Jack to race in South Australia in December. South Australian stewards have dealt with the discredited Jack. When Jack was caught out training the horses SA stewards publicly stated Turnbull would be charged. What has happened? Nothing it seems!

Amanda Turnbull is a protected species. Could it be she is protected by people in high places who are not acknowledging their conflict of interests? Maybe.

The use of this particular steroid is fraught with danger for vets and mug trainers because they can easily stuff up the withholding period. The drug, in its injectable form, is for treatment of dematological and arthritic conditions in dogs, cats and horses. It seems to be widely used but the fact remains it is a steroid and you should pay the penalty if your horse is swabbed in competition with the drug in its system. No excuse, goodbye Amanda.

[Messenger]

Trevor this was her saviour last time

The substance was supposedly given by a vet and recorded by Turnbull in her treatment book, with instructions about a suggested withholding period followed.

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/racing/turnbull-positive-swab-decision-could-promote-suspension-rethink-20180317-p4z4ty.html

And I would not be surprised to hear something similar again, so there would seem to be a problem in our sport - when a trainer is following veterinary advice

It is a steroid like many of the treatments we humans use
I believe it requires a penalty but I don't have as big a problem with it as I would if it was shown that the horse did not need treatment and the use of the drug was to enhance performance

[Showgrounds]

Sorry to disagree Kev. It is a performance enhancer if it has turned up in a swab, you can be sure of that. HRNSW pretty well spelt that out two years ago.

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?nkews_id=39451

It will also be interesting to see the outcome of KerryAnn Morris's positive to levamisole. I've sold plenty of levamisole products over the years for worming chooks, birds, sheep and cattle for round and tape worms. If it is found in a horse's swab it has been administered off-label. All named levamisole products registered with the AVPMA are either oral or pour-on drenches. It is NOT approved for use on horses. Apart from having narrow safety levels in horses it is thought to, or known to, metabolize into other performance enhancing substances in horses.

I suspect it masks these substances, which is why it is banned.

David Aiken copped a $5000 fine in 2018 after one of his horses returned a positive to levamisole at Shepparton trials. HRNSW issued a Notice to Industry pointing out the fact that levamisole is a class 1 drug and is banned and carries a MANDATORY 5 year disqualification. No doubt the KerryAnn / Peters Jr & And Morris defence will cite Aiken's fine as a more suitable penalty but if HRNSW notified all licences it is 5 years then it should be 5 years. It will be interesting to see how the image-senstive HRNSW handles a matter involving one of it's poster children.

And Amanda will, no doubt, be thumbing through the pages of the crooked trainers' encyclopaedia of implausible excuses. Lightning does strike twice around her stable.

[Messenger]

I thought Kate Gath would have been asked why she stayed 3 fence with Even money favourite Pacifico Dream in a 7 horse race

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=GE170421#GEM17042101

[Messenger]

The Stewards Report

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=EH130321

Additionally, although Stewards were able to confirm that Mr Nicholson had indeed ‘hocked’ BULLYS DELIGHT numerous times in the home straight as well as utilising his whip on numerous occasions outside the requirement of the rules, Stewards could not be comfortably satisfied that had this not occurred the placings would have changed. At a subsequent inquiry, Mr Nicholson pleaded guilty to a charge issued under the provisions of AHRR168(1)(e) – improper driving, in that in the home straight on the final occasion, Mr Nicholson dropped his right foot from the sulky stirrup and deliberately made contact with the hind leg of BULLYS DELIGHT (hocking) on numerous occasions. Stewards fined Mr Nicholson $2000 and in addition suspended his driver’s licence for a period to commence midnight 13th of March 2021 and expire midnight 20 March 2021. Additionally, Mr Nicholson pleaded guilty to a charge issued under AHRR156(2)(a), in that in the home straight on the final occasion, he utilised his whip with more than a wrist only flicking motion whilst engaging force from his elbow and shoulder as well as failing to maintain a rein in each hand. Mr Nicholson was fined $1000 and his driver’s licence was suspended for a period to commence midnight the 28th of March 2021 and expire midnight the 25th of April 2021 these suspensions being cumulative. In determining penalty, Stewards took into account the infractions occurred in the LADBROKES TASMANIA CUP as well as Mr Nicholson’s blatant disregard for the rules in both instances. All parties were informed at the conclusion of the protest hearing that Stewards would be conducting an inquiry into whether AHRR174(1) should be invoked.

Inquiry Completed

https://dpipwe.tas.gov.au/racing/stewards-inquiries-decisions

You can click on the Decision column to get the full decision in pdf form

Bullys Delight relegated from 1st to 14th

[Showgrounds]

There are two ways of looking at this decision. It is either a dark day for harness racing or it is the red letter day when harness racing grew up and set the tone for all types of betting sports. I am firmly in the latter's camp.

No doubt there will be internal outrage and trainers questioning how they are to get the optimum performance from their horses. Why, some of them might fall into the trap of using illegal performance enhancers. Perish the thought!

[Messenger]

https://nationaltrotguide.com.au/tas-cup-case-far-from-over-after-inquiry-strips-win-from-connections/?fbclid=IwAR0B0QntY8sIALz-Qy8HR1Q-8avNkUV2ny5rJhzPrMHiuDEMK98pz2PfxBY

More on it

I like how Murrihy said, " would be viewed as an affront by any fair-minded person "

John ( note use of first name constantly in article ) says
"If you've broken the rules to allegedly gain an advantage, then you can't keep the race"

Great IMO

[Yabbie]

https://nationaltrotguide.com.au/tas-cup-case-far-from-over-after-inquiry-strips-win-from-connections/?fbclid=IwAR0B0QntY8sIALz-Qy8HR1Q-8avNkUV2ny5rJhzPrMHiuDEMK98pz2PfxBY

More on it

I like how Murrihy said, " would be viewed as an affront by any fair-minded person "

John ( note use of first name constantly in article ) says
"If you've broken the rules to allegedly gain an advantage, then you can't keep the race"

Great IMO

I think the use of 'John' is to distinguish him from Rhys - you can't just say Nicholson ...

[Messenger]

Paul Courts should have gone with John Nicholson - jùst John makes him sound like a crony

UNBELIEVABLE today - The Age that can Never spare a line for harness racing, has a lengthy report on the demotion

[Showgrounds]

Paul Courts should have gone with John Nicholson - jùst John makes him sound like a crony

UNBELIEVABLE today - The Age that can Never spare a line for harness racing, has a lengthy report on the demotion

Yes, sounds like a crony. The reason could be that he is. It would have been fitting had he sought to interview Ray Murrihy but that is not the modus operandi for industry apologists.

[Messenger]

Mangini pleads guilty in horse doping case

From at least in or about 2011 through at least in or about March 2020, Mangini and his conspirators manufactured, sold, and shipped millions of dollars' worth of adulterated and misbranded equine drugs, including performance-enhancing drugs (“PEDs”) intended to be administered to racehorses for the purpose of improving those horses' race performance in order to win races and obtain prize money. Mangini, a former pharmacist whose license was suspended in 2016, sold these drugs through several direct-to-consumer websites designed to appeal to racehorse trainers and owners, including, among others, “horseprerace.com” and “racehorsemeds.com.”

http://www.harnesslink.com/USA/Mangini-pleads-guilty-in-horse-doping-case

I cannot remember the leading 2yo trainer's name but he used to move on all his horses at the end of the season 'because he did not want to compete with the chemists' - LOL Mangini was a pharmacist!
(He figured ability/education was more to the forefront than drugs in 2yo racing)

[Messenger]

I thought Kate Gath would have been asked why she stayed 3 fence with Even money favourite Pacifico Dream in a 7 horse race

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=GE170421#GEM17042101

I finally remembered to check the Stewards Report on this one - nothing!
Is 3 fence in a slowish first half for this class of horse, the spot you want to be on a $2.10 fav in a 7 horse race
Tell me what I am missing?
(I am not saying she would have beaten General Dodge as it panned out but why didn't she come out and give her horse every chance?)

[aussiebreno]

I finally remembered to check the Stewards Report on this one - nothing!
Is 3 fence in a slowish first half for this class of horse, the spot you want to be on a $2.10 fav in a 7 horse race
Tell me what I am missing?
(I am not saying she would have beaten General Dodge as it panned out but why didn't she come out and give her horse every chance?)

She was $2.10 based on probability of leading or at least being behind leader.

General Dodge was its price based on probability of being death seat.

Reactor Now was its price based on probability of being in no mans land from gate #7.

She did try to get out of the gate but General Dodge just had too much speed. Once the positions took shape General Dodge looked a good thing (say $2) and Reactor Now (say $2.50) odds would have drastically shortened. Leave no options but for Pacifico Dreams odds to drift out in running. So in real time was really a $10 shot once it ended up 3 pegs - which was no fault of the drive. Lachie McIntosh with a lap to go notes 'speed map turned on its head'. Not too many times anyone would really have a problem with a $10 shot staying 3 pegs instead of sitting in death against two shorties.

[Messenger]

Thanks Brendan, you often give me an alternative way of looking at things :D

[Messenger]

Steve Matson gets off his 12mth Disqualification (Long Read)

http://www.harness.org.au/news/uploads/Z230%202019%20Matson%20v%20Harness%20Racing%20Vict oria%20(Decision)1.pdf

Matthew Craven cops $500 for mouthing off (2 more clicks to get to details)

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-matthew-craven/

[Messenger]

Lisa Miles took Nota Replica to Menangle last week and it ran a shocker beaten 46m.
Change of trainers and last night it was pipped late in 1.50.6 (seconds faster than he has ever gone before)
All the more remarkable as it generally needs its races spaced. I know some will point to Menangle being much faster than say Bendigo and forgive last weeks run due to travel and point to last night being a shorter trip
BUT I will be interested in the Stewards Report to see if it gets a QIP ?
I sometimes find NSW Stewards Reports pretty bare

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=PC150521#PCM15052104

[Messenger]

I am surprised that Josh Aiken was only cautioned for shifting ground on Sirletic in R8 at Melton last night, I thought he came close to knocking Idealsomemagic down when he went up a dead-end on the inside and decided to come out (regardless)

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX220521#MXM22052101

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48303

8 years for a cheat - why can't Vic's stewards get these powers!

[Showgrounds]

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48303

8 years for a cheat - why can't Vic's stewards get these powers!

Fresh back from a 5 year and 3 months disqualification in 2013 wouldn't have helped his cause. Interesting that the latest disqualification was for using levamisole. More interesting will be how Kerryann Morris's case will go for the same substance.

Even more interesting is how HRNSW did a story on Russo a while back stating he had come back after "taking a break for a while" or words to that effect. No mention that break was for. It did say that his mate Luke McCarthy gave him a couple of boxes at his stables when he came back.

My bones tell me we have heard the last from the NSW stewards.

[Showgrounds]

26 March 2021 - Ms Amanda Turnbull – HRNSW Stewards have commenced an investigation in relation to a report from the Australian Racing Forensic Laboratory (ARFL) that Triamcinolone Acetonide had been detected in the pre-race blood sample taken from WHOS MY MOTHER NZ prior to it running in race 3, the CORDINA FOOD CO NSW OAKS HEAT 1 (2400 metres) conducted at Menangle on Saturday 20 February 2021. The “B” sample has been confirmed by Racing Analytical Services LTD (RASL) in Victoria. The investigation is continuing.

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=47657

Others listed: Morris, Wade, Hewitt, Russo

Amanda Turnbull pleaded guilty yesterday and copped three months.

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48373



Still wondering when the SA stewards are going to charge her!

[Showgrounds]

My bones tell me we have heard the last from the NSW stewards.

I meant to say "My bones tell me we have NOT heard the last from the NSW stewards"!

[Messenger]

Amanda Turnbull pleaded guilty yesterday and copped three months.

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48373



Still wondering when the SA stewards are going to charge her!

She has appealed the NSW disqualification
Info on Triamcinolone.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triamcinolone

see below Kevin Pizzuto being investigated over the same substance

[Messenger]

I meant to say "My bones tell me we have NOT heard the last from the NSW stewards"!

A comprehensive summary of what HRNSW have done this month

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48372

[Showgrounds]

A comprehensive summary of what HRNSW have done this month

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48372

The stewards are certainly earning their keep, aren't they!

Amanda Turnbull submitted a guilty plea then lodges an appeal the next day and is immediately granted a say of proceedings! What gives? I thought 3 months was reasonably lenient given she had been given the same penalty, later beaten on appeal, in 2018. Maybe she thinks lightning strikes twice, maybe she will be given a harsher penalty.

The horse in question, Whos Your Mother, won the Young Oaks 20 days later and pulled up lame with a suspected broken or fractured pedal bone. With only the stewards' report to go with you are left joining the dots. The drug in question is an injectable corticosteroid, two of its functions being to open airways (pretty useful in a racehorse) and to be injected into joints such as knees or hocks.

Racing Victoria clarified the use of this product 4 years ago requiring 8 clear days between treatment and competing in any jump-out, trial or race. This directive came about due to trainers being caught out by the the recommended WHP for the drug.

Whos Your Mother was believed to have broken her pedal bone. The stewards' report for that race made mention of a post-race vet inspection which revealed the pedal bone issue. One can assume the positive swab the previous start occurred from the vet injecting either a hock or a fetlock? A post race swab was also taken from the filly at Young, the result of which has yet to be made public.

Whatever the outcome a steroid has been used and found in a swab and the trainer is accountable under the HRA rules. And, in this case, the trainer cannot claim ignorance. Not that this seems to matter much!

[Messenger]

What has become of Horse Welfare, if people are using drugs to reduce inflammation in rheumatic joints but then continuing to race the horse
There are many that claim to be horse lovers but they are NOT. Horses are their income and they have no more regard for them than a mechanic might have for a car

[Messenger]

NSW: Ms Amanda Turnbull - NSW Supreme Court Interim Injunction Granted
The NSW Supreme Court granted an interim injunction until 9am on Wednesday 9 June 2021 after NSW Racing Appeals Tribunal advised that it was of the preliminary opinion that a stay be refused

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48426

[DRUIDRACING]

plead guilty then go to court..........? why just do the time

[Messenger]

Why NOT just do the time? Is that what you meant Steve?
She obviously did not expect that penalty, I guess

[Messenger]

NSW: Ms Amanda Turnbull - NSW Supreme Court Interim Injunction Granted
The NSW Supreme Court granted an interim injunction until 9am on Wednesday 9 June 2021 after NSW Racing Appeals Tribunal advised that it was of the preliminary opinion that a stay be refused

https://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48426

On 8 June 2021, the NSW Racing Appeals Tribunal granted Ms Turnbull a Stay. Consequently, the hearing for the Supreme Court injunction was vacated.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48483

[Messenger]

Ryan Duffy 15mths Disqualification
BUT you will have to look up the Rules to find out why

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-penalty-decision-ryan-duffy/

193. (1) A person shall not attempt to stomach tube or stomach tube a horse nominated for a race or event within 48 hours of the commencement of the race or event.

Apology - there was a link to full decision

[Speedy]

Ryan Duffy 15mths Disqualification
BUT you will have to look up the Rules to find out why
Pathetic report HRV stewards

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-penalty-decision-ryan-duffy/

193. (1) A person shall not attempt to stomach tube or stomach tube a horse nominated for a race or event within 48 hours of the commencement of the race or event.


No need to look up the rule Kevin. It was all in the link that it said to click on.

[Messenger]

No need to look up the rule Kevin. It was all in the link that it said to click on.

Thanks Patrick, I have to slow down and read things more carefully

[Messenger]

Why would you leave the position of HRNSW Chief Steward to be Deputy Chief for HRV

https://www.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/hrv-welcomes-grant-adams-to-integrity-team/

Don't you love/hate the way they refer to each other as Mr Adams, Mr Day - even our pollies don't refer to their colleagues as Mr Morrison, Mr Frydenburg but I suppose they use their titles a bit, PM etc

[aussiebreno]

Why would you leave the position of HRNSW Chief Steward to be Deputy Chief for HRV

https://www.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/hrv-welcomes-grant-adams-to-integrity-team/

Don't you love/hate the way they refer to each other as Mr Adams, Mr Day - even our pollies don't refer to their colleagues as Mr Morrison, Mr Frydenburg but I suppose they use their titles a bit, PM etc

Seeing a Bentley as Steward in NSW brings back some green light memories

[Messenger]

I have read some concerns about how R6 at Menangle panned out yesterday
The well supported winner (1,2 &4 all from the same stable and owners) was certainly never challenged by the other 2 supported runners
We will have to wait and see if the stewards have anything to say - NOTHING

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ME220621#MEC22062102

[Showgrounds]

I have read some concerns about how R6 at Menangle panned out yesterday
The well supported winner (1,2 &4 all from the same stable and owners) was certainly never challenged by the other 2 supported runners
We will have to wait and see if the stewards have anything to say - NOTHING

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ME220621#MEC22062102

Three blind mice doing the stewards jobs I fear. No questions asked of the three drivers on the most favoured horses or the connections of the well plunged winner. I've seen more competitive track work than this race. Such a poor look.

[Messenger]

Another one from the same source

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=NR210521#NRC21052107

Interesting to watch the neck of the leader on the pegs who seems to make room for the held up favourite to get out in the straight after his driver looks to the right but it is probably an illusion as the stewards didn’t see anything

[Messenger]

And how did Kevin Pizzuto find so much improvement in Ready To Bloom in the space of a week after an ordinary 8th last week. So much so that he started in the red despite not having won for 2yrs

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ME220621#MEC22062115

Once again no questions asked in the stewards report

[Showgrounds]

And how did Kevin Pizzuto find so much improvement in Ready To Bloom in the space of a week after an ordinary 8th last week. So much so that he started in the red despite not having won for 2yrs

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ME220621#MEC22062115

Once again no questions asked in the stewards report

And no pre-race blood test either. Backed into the red, nothing to see here! I see the trainer has already been charged in March for a positive to the same corticosteroid that Amanda Turnbull was outed for. Takes an extremely great trainer to produce a struggling plodder second up and pull of a plunge to win so easily after just 6 weeks in their care. Or not.

[Messenger]

We sometimes think Victorian stewards QIP's are a token gesture but at least they are asking the question and confirming that they are seeing what punters are seeing
I think NSW stewards reports come out quickly because there is nothing in them!

[djgood]

NSW is a basketcase going backwards at a rate of knots and losing lifelong industry participants

[Showgrounds]

We sometimes think Victorian stewards QIP's are a token gesture but at least they are asking the question and confirming that they are seeing what punters are seeing
I think NSW stewards reports come out quickly because there is nothing in them!

Merge HRNSW with South Australia, what do you reckon?

[Messenger]

The protest upheld in R2 at Shep tonight
The leader did hang out at the entrance to the straight but did he take the 2nd place-getter out?
Keep the replay running to see the head on. It is interesting to note that the 2nd place-getter seemed to have a tendency to run off itself

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SP300621#SPC30062110

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=BN131020

This is from Oct 13 last year R1 Bendigo
When considering the circumstances of the race and the statements of the driver, stewards did not feel the tactics adopted were so unreasonable as to warrant further action. A post-race veterinary examination was conducted on the gelding, with no obvious abnormalities detected. Stewards intend to analyse the wagering data of the event.
This is the Supplementary Report that covers Oct 13

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=45450

No mention of the wagering analysis

Where does one find the stewards decision on their analysis?

ps This is the race link

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BN131020#BNC13102004

[Messenger]

HRV Chairman of Stewards Brett Day was kind enough to supply me with an answer to the above.
If there were to be charges/follow up action due to wagering analysis we would find it in a Supplementary Report

[Messenger]

Commencing today, two Police officers will be seconded to the Office of the Racing Integrity Commissioner for six months and will work with the racing codes and broader industry to better understand the criminal and integrity risks within Victorian racing.

https://harnesslink.com/australia/police-to-work-with-victorian-racing-industry/

[Showgrounds]

Commencing today, two Police officers will be seconded to the Office of the Racing Integrity Commissioner for six months and will work with the racing codes and broader industry to better understand the criminal and integrity risks within Victorian racing.

https://harnesslink.com/australia/police-to-work-with-victorian-racing-industry/

Translated into common sense English - "We haven't got a clue but this will make it seem like we are doing something".

[Messenger]

There was no ADJ INQ next to the last 2 horses in the last race at Melton on June 26 but there must have been as it has appeared in the Supplementary Report

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48803

Have a look at the race

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX260621#MXM26062110

Lee and IMO Alford (to a lesser extent) pretty lucky to get away with these drives

[Messenger]

There was no ADJ INQ next to the last 2 horses in the last race at Melton on June 26 but there must have been as it has appeared in the Supplementary Report

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=48803

Have a look at the race

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX260621#MXM26062110

Lee and IMO Alford (to a lesser extent) pretty lucky to get away with these drives

I have read elsewhere that they only took 34.3 to the 1200m mark (checked and correct)
When Lochinvar Art ran the incredible 1.48.6 Tk Rec for the distance he took 34.7 to the 1200m

[Messenger]

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-lisa-miles/

We will have to wait and see why Lisa Miles received no enforced penalty (other than trainer/driver share of first) as it takes a week for VRT written decisions to be posted

One thing I do know however is the owners just lost the lion's share of $3,990. You would think that warranted some penalty

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BN230920#BNC23092004

This is the lowdown on Synephrine

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synephrine

I hope it isn't one of those stories that the horse got into the orange orchard
All may be explained satisfactorily when the ruling is posted
You would think that a summary of the reasons could be posted with the story release instead of -
"We will tell you why next week"

[Messenger]

Read about this elsewhere
From R6 Albion Park yesterday
Have a look at how dad on No.2 gives up the 1x1 to his son No.5 who was stuck wide

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=AP130721#APC13072106

The stewards took no action!
Dads might but our industry does itself no favours

[Showgrounds]

Read about this elsewhere
From R6 Albion Park yesterday
Have a look at how dad on No.2 gives up the 1x1 to his son No.5 who was stuck wide

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=AP130721#APC13072106

The stewards took no action!
Dads might but our industry does itself no favours

Pulled the 1x1 horse back so hard he banged his head with the winner, which had to check off him. Stewards didn't see any of this, apparently. Perhaps they were patting their Labradors at the time.

[Messenger]

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=AP240721#APM24072102

If you watch the finish of the Qld Oaks you will see pretty damning evidence of Michael Stanley hocking Soho Broadway - not exactly the actions of a horse lover

There is an adjourned Stewards Inquiry

[Messenger]

From Tuesday's Albion Park Stewards Report

Supplementary Report:

The inquiry set down for today with driver Michael Stanley from Saturday 24th July 2021, Race 6, the TAB 2021 Queensland Oaks, was postponed to a time and date to be determined.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=AP270721

[Showgrounds]

Inspired by this year's Tasmanian Cup no doubt. And if he says his foot just slipped and he was trying to get his foot back......phhtt! Pull the other one. After watching the replay several times he deserves a long spell on the sidelines.

[Messenger]

Yes Trev, that kicking action is hard to believe. You have to wonder what happened to his brain, did he forget about racing being all about telecasts, replays, cameras :confused:

[aussiebreno]

If he does get suspended make the most of it and back his horses that have a driver change Stanley off and another driver on. Case in point Sohol Bollinger last two starts.

[djgood]

seems a lot of open enquiries in NSW from last year , surely these enquiries could be sped up 8-12 months after getting a positive swab you can still be training seems a bit ridiculous

[Messenger]

The Douglas stable is dominating down here in Vic David.
We are coming up 1000 days since Glenn and Ellen T's offence for which they were disqualified but are yet to serve
Oh wait but it is Julie not Glenn training them all :rolleyes:

[Messenger]

What do you make of Jack Trainor's drive on the $1.45 fav in R8 at Menangle, he is on Hugo George behind the leader

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=PC100821#PCC10082104

It would appear no questions from the stewards

[Messenger]

What do you make of Jack Trainor's drive on the $1.45 fav in R8 at Menangle, he is on Hugo George behind the leader

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=PC100821#PCC10082104

It would appear no questions from the stewards

RACE 8 – EVEKARE ASSISTED LIVING PACE – 1609 metres

HUGO GEORGE NZ– Stewards questioned driver Jack Trainor with regards to the tactics he adopted on the gelding throughout the event, in particular his decision approaching the 250 metres whereby he elected to shift his runner wider across the back of GIMMEFIVEMINUTESMORE NZ and seek clear running to the outside rather than wait for an opportunity to present between the leader MAJOR OBAHMA and GIMMEFIVEMINUTESMORE NZ. Mr Trainor advised Stewards that the gelding was new to his stable and he hoped to lead in the event however he was unsure of the gate speed possessed by the gelding. Mr Trainor advised Stewards that MAJOR OBAHMA had begun better to his outside and he did not want to get into a speed dual with that runner in the early stages and elected to take a sit on that runner’s back and hoped to outsprint MAJOR OBAHMA over the concluding stages. Mr Trainor explained that as a result of the tempo being slower than expected GIVEMEFIVEMINUTESMORE NZ had continued to stick on to the outside of MAJOR OBAHMA longer than he expected and as a result approaching the 400 metres he commenced to restrain his gelding somewhat to give him an alternative option of shifting wider across the back of GIMMEFIVEMINUTESMORE NZ in case a run didn’t present to the inside or outside of the leader. Mr Trainor further explained that at the point passing the 250 metres both runners continued to maintain their position and he made a conscious decision to shift HUGO GEORGE NZ wider as a run had not fully developed between MAJOR OBAHMA and GIMMEFIVEMINUTESMORE NZ at that stage. After considering the explanation provided by Mr Trainor and reviewing the available films, in particular the head on footage of the home straight, which confirmed that Mr Trainor had commenced his shift up the track prior to Mr Green applying the whip to MAJOR OBAHMA in the home straight and that runner responding to his driving ensuring that a full run becoming available for HUGO GEORGE NZ to progress between MAJOR OBAHMA and GIVEMEFIVEMINUTESMORE NZ, and as a result believed the tactics of Mr Trainor at this stage of the event were reasonable in all the circumstances and determined to note his comments.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=PC100821

At the very least it was a terrible drive

[Messenger]

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-lisa-miles/

We will have to wait and see why Lisa Miles received no enforced penalty (other than trainer/driver share of first) as it takes a week for VRT written decisions to be posted

One thing I do know however is the owners just lost the lion's share of $3,990. You would think that warranted some penalty

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BN230920#BNC23092004

This is the lowdown on Synephrine

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synephrine

I hope it isn't one of those stories that the horse got into the orange orchard
All may be explained satisfactorily when the ruling is posted
You would think that a summary of the reasons could be posted with the story release instead of -
"We will tell you why next week"

Answer posted on VRT thread

http://www.harnessracingforum.com/showthread.php?18020-VRT-Victorian-Racing-Tribunal&p=68774#post68774

[Messenger]

From Tuesday's Albion Park Stewards Report

Supplementary Report:

The inquiry set down for today with driver Michael Stanley from Saturday 24th July 2021, Race 6, the TAB 2021 Queensland Oaks, was postponed to a time and date to be determined.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=AP270721

Remembered to search follow up Albion Park Stewards Reports and Unbelievable, he only got a fine! ($1,000) for blatantly kicking his horse in a Gp1 showcase race

[Messenger]

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-michael-bellman/

Michael Bellman has been given a 3 month suspension (from training and driving?) for inappropriate behaviour (which he has appealed)

I can't see you winning your appeal Michael, I would consider taking the suspension considering that racing could easily close down in the next 3 months.
I am not condoning his actions or wanting him to escape penalty, just saying it might be a smart move

[Yabbie]

If you knew the full facts you would also appeal. Its an extremely harsh penalty

[Messenger]

Maybe Carol, PeterProfit is in agreement with you, but in this day and age his chances are slim (I don't think you could put a whip between your wife's legs without first asking) and my suggestion was simply a tactical one

[Messenger]

I am starting to get the picture now Carol

And some might remember this guilty plea from Matty Craven for an incident that happened the day after Michael Bellman's inappropriate whip meeting

Particulars of charge:
1. You were, at all relevant times, licensed by HRV and bound by the Australian Harness Racing Rules.
2. On 10 October 2020, you attended Tabcorp Park Melton and engaged in a conversation with licensed trainer and driver Mr Michael Bellman in or around the drivers’ room.
3. In the course of that conversation, you threatened Mr Bellman, in that you directed the following comments to him:
a. “You will keep ****”
b. Words to the effect of: “I will back myself in any day to beat the **** out of you”

Plea: Guilty

[Messenger]

Interesting that Sofia Arvidsson suspended for knocking down Michael Bellman's horse

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=KI210821#MXM21082106

[Messenger]

From the Stewards Report for last Friday at Miludra

RACE 10 – GOOD DEAL TYRES PACE (1790 MS)

Loyola Rocknrolla over-raced during the middle stages when positioned outside of the leader.

Reece Moore, driver of Missblissfullbeach was cautioned for the manner in which he shifted ground near the 200m which resulted in Fiery Mac and Gilded being inconvenienced.

Lilbitahenrytee was held up and unable to obtain a clear run when finishing the race without being fully tested prior to finishing in 3rd place beaten 4m. Jordan Leedham, driver of Lilbitahenrytee was questioned regarding his tactics adopted inside the final 100m as a run presented to the inside of the leader Lucinda Jamar. Mr Leedham explained that given the close proximity to the winning post and that he considered that Alex Ashwood, driver of the leader (Lucinda Jamar) would correct his drive and Lilbitahenrytee may therefore be unable to progress into the run he elected not to pursue this opportunity. Mr Leedham added that he considered had he have taken this run, that Lilbitahenrytee would have remained in 3rd place. Although Stewards were satisfied that Lilbithenrytee would still have finished in 3rd place, Mr Leedham was advised that in future he would be expected to pursue such opportunities that exist at a vital stage of a race.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=ML200821

Strange that Jordan was only interested in following Alex

Here is the race. He was unlikely to improve on 3rd but head on footage showed a big gap half way down the straight

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ML200821#MLC20082107

[Showgrounds]

You can get away with pretty well any dodgy drive with no crowd in attendance. In times when crowds went to the trots, instead of protests at Parliament House, the hooting and hollering from disgruntled punters would prevent the stewards from having a power nap in their stands. The AG Hunter Stand at the Melbourne Showgrounds acted like a gigantic megaphone when horse were returning to scale. Any crook driver knew of the crowd's dissatisfaction. Young Leedham's drive was a strange one, you cannot win if you just follow the leader.

[Messenger]

We see drivers get irritable when a following horse is touching their helmet but David Magri (1x1 Columbias Deecee) went too far with full on head butts and you would expect the stewards to take some action as he caused My High Peak to gallop
Amazingly My High Peak recovered and won
The offence happened as they were approaching the bell

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA270821#BAC27082108

[Showgrounds]

We see drivers get irritable when a following horse is touching their helmet but David Magri (1x1 Columbias Deecee) went too far with full on head butts and you would expect the stewards to take some action as he caused My High Peak to gallop
Amazingly My High Peak recovered and won
The offence happened as they were approaching the bell

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA270821#BAC27082108

At no stage did I see the winning horse make contact with the driver's head but he deliberately turned around and gave it three big head butts. How did the sleepy stewards miss that?

A pretty ordinary maiden field but the winner was a terrific run considering the ground it lost and made up. Only its third start and is bred from a good family.

[Messenger]

At no stage did I see the winning horse make contact with the driver's head but he deliberately turned around and gave it three big head butts. How did the sleepy stewards miss that?

A pretty ordinary maiden field but the winner was a terrific run considering the ground it lost and made up. Only its third start and is bred from a good family.

The Stewards Report is total nonsense:

Approaching the 1000m, My High Peak commenced to over-race slightly and raced in close proximity to the outside sulky wheel of Columbias Deecee (D Magri) resulting in My High Peak galloping. Stewards intend to interview David Magri, driver of Columbias Deecee regarding his actions during this section.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=BA270821

Blind Freddy can see that My High Peak galloped straight after being head-butted by David Magri

[Messenger]

The Stewards Report is total nonsense:

Approaching the 1000m, My High Peak commenced to over-race slightly and raced in close proximity to the outside sulky wheel of Columbias Deecee (D Magri) resulting in My High Peak galloping. Stewards intend to interview David Magri, driver of Columbias Deecee regarding his actions during this section.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=BA270821

Blind Freddy can see that My High Peak galloped straight after being head-butted by David Magri

After communication with the Stewards apparently "My High Peak commenced to over-race slightly and raced in close proximity to the outside sulky wheel of Columbias Deecee (D Magri) resulting in My High Peak galloping' does not suggest My High Peak's galloping was its own doing :confused:

We will have to watch for the result of the stewards inquiries

[Showgrounds]

Should have gone to Specsavers.

That is the only viable excuse the officiating panel could use, apart to admitting to incompetence.

[Messenger]

It is a big deal IMO for if they are prepared to ignore/go easy on some things then the question of Integrity becomes 'rubbery'
They haven't yet done this but I think the Stewards Report is unnecessarily vague and could have put the whole incident to bed on the night

[Adaptor]

Interesting one in a 5 horse field at Bendigo. Out of range of the camera just after the standing start:
Race 4, September 1.

Ashley Ainsworth, driver of Namoscar, pleaded guilty to a charge under AHR Rule 168(1)(e) for improper driving in that passing the 2000m whilst Namoscar was in a gallop he unnecessarily applied significant force to either rein and thereby the horses’ mouth and bit which in the opinion of the Stewards was improper. In assessing penalty Stewards considered the HRV Stewards Minimum Penalty Guidelines, placing weight on Mr Ainsworth’s guilty plea, poor offence record and that the incident fell well short of accepted industry standards and conduct. Stewards were particularly mindful that the post-race veterinary examination of Namoscar did not reveal any significant findings. Stewards accordingly imposed a 6 week suspension of Mr Ainsworth’s licence to drive in races and a fine of $1,000. Due to the seriousness of the matter Stewards ordered the suspension commence immediately.

Mr Ainsworth was advised that in accordance with the HRV Participant Mentoring Policy he must attend a mandatory session before the HRV Participant Skills Panel prior to driving in races again.

Mr Ainsworth was further advised due to his repeated offending he is required to show cause as to why his Grade A driver’s licence should not be varied in accordance with AHR Rule 90(7).

[Beltane]

My High Peak washup:

RACE 4 –ALDEBARAN PARK VICBRED PLATINUM MAIDEN TROT (2200 MS)

David Magri, driver of Columbias Deecee was questioned in relation to a matter approaching the 1000m, where Mr Magri’s head was directed backwards as My High Peak galloped. Upon consideration of the evidence, inclusive of the footage available it was established that approaching the 1000m My High Peak commenced to over-race and raced in close proximity behind Columbias Deecee. As My High Peak’s head was then positioned immediately over Mr Magri’s right shoulder and making contact with the outside sulky wheel of Columbias Deecee, Mr Magri explained that for safety reasons he then endeavoured to prevent that gelding from racing any closer in his vicinity by directing his head backwards. A short distance after, My High Peak then galloped. Given the associated safety considerations and that Mr Magri had not initiated any movement by his head until My High Peak had raced in extreme close proximity to his right shoulder, no further action was deemed necessary in those circumstances. Furthermore, Stewards noted the racing manners of My High Peak during this section, that the gelding was only having its third race start and therefore pursued no action against driver Jackie Barker.

Nothing to see here, move right along. Fair crack of the whip, the replay is not a good look, and the only redeeming thing to come out the race was that My High Peak and the lady driver showed a lot ticker in hitting the winning line first!

[Showgrounds]

My High Peak washup:

RACE 4 –ALDEBARAN PARK VICBRED PLATINUM MAIDEN TROT (2200 MS)

David Magri, driver of Columbias Deecee was questioned in relation to a matter approaching the 1000m, where Mr Magri’s head was directed backwards as My High Peak galloped. Upon consideration of the evidence, inclusive of the footage available it was established that approaching the 1000m My High Peak commenced to over-race and raced in close proximity behind Columbias Deecee. As My High Peak’s head was then positioned immediately over Mr Magri’s right shoulder and making contact with the outside sulky wheel of Columbias Deecee, Mr Magri explained that for safety reasons he then endeavoured to prevent that gelding from racing any closer in his vicinity by directing his head backwards. A short distance after, My High Peak then galloped. Given the associated safety considerations and that Mr Magri had not initiated any movement by his head until My High Peak had raced in extreme close proximity to his right shoulder, no further action was deemed necessary in those circumstances. Furthermore, Stewards noted the racing manners of My High Peak during this section, that the gelding was only having its third race start and therefore pursued no action against driver Jackie Barker.

Nothing to see here, move right along. Fair crack of the whip, the replay is not a good look, and the only redeeming thing to come out the race was that My High Peak and the lady driver showed a lot ticker in hitting the winning line first!

The stewards report resembles something I just stood in down my back paddock. Except that came out of a steer. The stewards are taking us all for complete mugs!

[Messenger]

Trainer Cassandra O'Brien needs to make the most of R4 at Ouyen today as it will be her last for 3mths

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vcat-review-cassandra-obrien/

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=OU190921#OUC19092105

[Messenger]

HRV Stewards hereby notify the industry that the practise of forcefully and severely applying pressure to either side of the rein to endeavour to return a horse to its correct gait or for any other purpose, is no longer considered an acceptable practise from a horse welfare perspective

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=49861

[Messenger]

PeterProfit thinks the stewards got it wrong and that Lola Wiedemann should not have copped 6 weeks for what was simply a mistake
Have a look at No.3 Misty Creek in the green and gold in R2 at Redcliffe here - the $1.25 favourite should have won by the length of the straight so I can't say I am worried about why Lola got 6 of the best

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=RE160921#REC16092106

[Messenger]

Pizzuto only fined for Class 3 Offence

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=49949

The drug:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Triamcinolone_acetonide

[Showgrounds]

Another interesting case in NSW, this one involving trainer Peter Russo's. A TCO2 reading above the threshold last Saturday night at Menangle from a pre-race blood test. Interesting wording; Russo has not been charged (yet) but has until midday next Monday "to make a submission".

Russo has recently featured positively in HRNSW media releases. Given his previous disqualifications, his submission will need to be pretty compelling. Do a Google search "peter russo hrnsw disqualification" but be prepared for plenty of reading!

[Messenger]

I am going to be an interested reader of the R2 Stewards Report for Ballarat tonight
The Nicholson stable quinellaed the race and both drivers received a QDT
Maybe all the other drivers should get a QDT as to why they let these two stitch up the race so beautifully

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=BA161021#BAM16102103

[Messenger]

We haven't got a head on and I know it was only 3rd v 2nd but surely McCarthy on the leader has drifted out and caused interference to young Lleyton Green's horse in the home straight

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=PC191021#PCC19102104

Protest dismissed

[Messenger]

The old PP is asking big questions about R3 at Globe Derby last night
and you can see why he might be
The favourite led as it said it would with the heavily backed Cavalryman on his back
Gaita Pullicino attacked the fav mercilessly throughout but as big a worry for me was the fact that the 1x1 horse was never asked for an effort by Samantha Pascoe and Cavalryman was always going to be able to get off the leaders back before the sprint lane even

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=GD231021#GDC23102102

[Messenger]

Jayden Brewin is gaining notoriety for all the wrong reasons and some are suggesting his recent 3 week suspension should have been classed as race fixing
I am going to class it as careless for the following reasons - the 8 horse who benefited from his wayward drive was always going to get the back of the favourite (1) and eventually the sprint lane so you would think needing the lead was not imperative
The way JB's head turns as if surprised to see the 8 splitting him and the leader
We are talking about the start of Race 3 below with JB driving the 2 horse

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=CH270921#CHC27092105

[Messenger]

Could Leigh Sutton on Blue Chip Delight have protested against the winner at Melton last night?
Bailey McDonough was suspended - I assume for taking the spot behind the leader when there was insufficient room
It would have been a totally different race - I reckon it would have been successful at the Meadowlands

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=MX301021#MXM30102102

[Messenger]

I understand that test results can be slow in coming but 11mths?

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/pending-vrt-hearing-leroy-obrien/

[Messenger]

I have read a suggestion that Jack Laugher's drive on $1.25 fav Captain Bellasario left a lot to be desired
Their point is that he could have got off the pegs before the straight
I was also surprised at his lack of urgency when the sprint lane came up
Take a look for yourself

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=YG041121#YGC04112102

[Showgrounds]

I have read a suggestion that Jack Laugher's drive on $1.25 fav Captain Bellasario left a lot to be desired
Their point is that he could have got off the pegs before the straight
I was also surprised at his lack of urgency when the sprint lane came up
Take a look for yourself

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=YG041121#YGC04112102

Agree, disinterested drive that did not appear to display any great sense of urgency even when the sprint lane opened up. And, with the leader so obviously displaying signs of defeat before the turn, no interest was shown in putting the horse into gaps you could park a truck in.

[Messenger]

It will be interesting to read what the stewards says about Rocknroll Rod being declared a non runner in R1 last night, I am thinking it is something the starter should have picked up as we all saw that he had his head over the gate at the start

[Messenger]

The ol PP is asking questions about R1 at Terang last night
Such as:
What was Alex Ashwood doing going that fast on the leader who has not got those times in its record
How did James Herbertson's horse run into the back of the fav
You would hope the Stewards Report might ask and have some answers
The Hargreaves horse was backed for plenty and 2nd up won very easily

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=TE091121#TEC09112106

[Messenger]

No answers for the above in the Stewards Report

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=TE091121

Why would the stewards consider the leader ran poorly when he has never run those times before?

[Messenger]

18mths for failing a pre-race blood test with the winning favourite

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-peter-obrien/

He got into trouble for the same thing with the same horse 3yrs ago and only got a fine

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=37617

This time they have already had a collect
If there is a next time, make it life.

This was the race

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ML300321#MLC30032106

[Messenger]

All Scott Garraway's horses (6) late scratchings from Miludra today
We await news

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ML191121#MLC19112101

[Messenger]

We will have to await the Stewards Report for Stawell today
In R5 we had a couple of runners protest against the winner for going into the sprint lane (which the replay clearly shows he did)
The protests were dismissed but I hope the SR gives us some clarity on what happens when a horse does this

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SW221121#SWC22112102

[Messenger]

All Scott Garraway's horses (6) late scratchings from Miludra today
We await news

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=ML191121#MLC19112101

Here is the Stewards Report

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=ML191121

Here is a charge against him, just announced but from July 30

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/pending-vrt-hearing-scott-garraway/

[Messenger]

We will have to await the Stewards Report for Stawell today
In R5 we had a couple of runners protest against the winner for going into the sprint lane (which the replay clearly shows he did)
The protests were dismissed but I hope the SR gives us some clarity on what happens when a horse does this

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=SW221121#SWC22112102

Here is the Stewards Report, it would seem that it is considered a minor offense if no other runner is impeded

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=SW221121

[Messenger]

I know we are used to sprint lanes and the belief that every runner should get a chance
however at Menangle they do not have a sprint lane
so when a leader rolls off the pegs on entering the straight,
a leader that has given a well backed horse a beautiful cart along,
why aren't the stewards asking questions?
If I suggest the above scenario is a perfect way to set up a race - very few are going to disagree
Take R1 at Menangle last night
I am not saying this had to be a set up BUT stewards have to be suspicious b@$!@^*& who have to ask questions

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/fields/race-fields/?mc=PC271121#PCM27112104

[Messenger]

Lotamuscle NZ underwent pre and post race veterinary examinations at Bathurst last night after sustaining lacerations to its neck in float incident prior to the 1st round of Inter Dominion heats at Menangle as previously advised in HRNSW Integrity Release dated Friday 26thNovember 2021 and Stewards Report from that Menangle meeting. After examination it was determined that the horses condition had improved from Menangle and it was passed fit to take its place in the 2nd round of the Inter Dominion series. Lotamuscle NZ raced at Menangle with a plastic burr attached to the offside rein, however given the lacerations to the geldings neck the burr was affixed in a reverse position with the burrs pointing away from the horses neck. The horse again completed the preliminary at Bathurst last night with the burr affixed in reverse. At the completion of the preliminary the horse was re-examined by HRNSW Regulatory Veterinarian Dr Martin Wainscott and displayed signs of the burr rubbing on the horses neck, at which time it was agreed that the burr would be removed and Lotamuscle NZ cleared to start in the event. The condition of Lotamuscle NZ will continue to be monitored by HRNSW Regulatory Veterinarians for the remainder of the Inter Dominion series.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=50674

Are we really supposed to believe this began as a float incident - give us a break!

It does not seem to be anywhere near Best Practice Animal Welfare
There are reports that red raw skin was visible on the horses neck

[Showgrounds]

Lotamuscle NZ underwent pre and post race veterinary examinations at Bathurst last night after sustaining lacerations to its neck in float incident prior to the 1st round of Inter Dominion heats at Menangle as previously advised in HRNSW Integrity Release dated Friday 26thNovember 2021 and Stewards Report from that Menangle meeting. After examination it was determined that the horses condition had improved from Menangle and it was passed fit to take its place in the 2nd round of the Inter Dominion series. Lotamuscle NZ raced at Menangle with a plastic burr attached to the offside rein, however given the lacerations to the geldings neck the burr was affixed in a reverse position with the burrs pointing away from the horses neck. The horse again completed the preliminary at Bathurst last night with the burr affixed in reverse. At the completion of the preliminary the horse was re-examined by HRNSW Regulatory Veterinarian Dr Martin Wainscott and displayed signs of the burr rubbing on the horses neck, at which time it was agreed that the burr would be removed and Lotamuscle NZ cleared to start in the event. The condition of Lotamuscle NZ will continue to be monitored by HRNSW Regulatory Veterinarians for the remainder of the Inter Dominion series.

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=50674

Are we really supposed to believe this began as a float incident - give us a break!

It does not seem to be anywhere near Best Practice Animal Welfare
There are reports that red raw skin was visible on the horses neck

If what the stewards say was true why wasn't the pricker removed altogether? Without seeing the gear I presume it was a straight rubber piece with burrs and attached to the lugging pole by two laces. The other style wraps diagonally around the pole, a less subtle piece of gear that cannot be reversed. So, who are the stewards trying to kid? Reversing the pricker renders it ineffective so it should have been removed. If connections objected then the horse should have been scratched. What we now know is the horse did not need a pricker (it won) and, by allowing a horse to run with a "lacerated neck" probably exacerbated the problem by the pole rubbing on its neck.

Whatever, it isn't a good look for harness racing. Again.

[Messenger]

Matty Craven replied to PP's article on Lotamuscle's wound.
Apparently prior to Heat 1, the colt he was travelling with bit him on the neck
It scabbed and so on the 2nd night even the reins aggravated it
He points out the real welfare problem is that the no race day treatment rules means you cannot even put white healer cream or vaseline on it

[Messenger]

Do we need to bring back fences instead of pegs (not really due to OH&S)
TrotsVision only showed the stewards footage once of the early stages of R3 at Melton
but I thought Come Say Hi may have gone inside more than a couple of pegs in order to keep the leaders back
Keeping Relentless Me out made a massive difference to the race so I hope this was not the case

[Messenger]

To do with above

Stewards inquired into an incident passing the 1300m where after taking evidence from drivers Kate Gath (Come Say Hi), Jack Laugher (Relentless Me) and review of the available replays it was established that Relentless Me was initially directed inwards when sufficiently clear of Come Say Hi and when shifting down to fully occupy the position following Interject, Come Say Hi continued to improve forward with momentum and when racing marginally to the inside of Relentless Me was tightened as that runner continued to shift inwards resulting in Come Say Hi racing inside the line of marker pegs prior to Relentless Me being directed outwards. In view of the circumstances Stewards were satisfied neither driver was at fault and took the matter no further.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=MX041221

Just watched it again and I call BS
Relentless Me was coming down and Kate Gath put her horse where there was no room for her cart to follow - she is lucky Jack didn't simply take Relentless Me's front legs out

[Yabbie]

To do with above

Stewards inquired into an incident passing the 1300m where after taking evidence from drivers Kate Gath (Come Say Hi), Jack Laugher (Relentless Me) and review of the available replays it was established that Relentless Me was initially directed inwards when sufficiently clear of Come Say Hi and when shifting down to fully occupy the position following Interject, Come Say Hi continued to improve forward with momentum and when racing marginally to the inside of Relentless Me was tightened as that runner continued to shift inwards resulting in Come Say Hi racing inside the line of marker pegs prior to Relentless Me being directed outwards. In view of the circumstances Stewards were satisfied neither driver was at fault and took the matter no further.

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=MX041221

Just watched it again and I call BS
Relentless Me was coming down and Kate Gath put her horse where there was no room for her cart to follow - she is lucky Jack didn't simply take Relentless Me's front legs out

Did you see the head on footage? - may possibly change your opinion. The boys on TrotsVision covered it Saturday night

[Messenger]

Carol, as I said in my first post on the incident, it was the stewards film of it on TrotsVision that showed Kate inside the pegs and made me curious but I only remember them showing it once.

[Yabbie]

I saw it again in an article on the HRV website - it gives you the opportunity to review closely and I'm pretty sure Brett Day also referred to it in the video
Try this link:

https://www.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/trots-review-tornado-joins-immortals-with-one-in-a-million-win/?fbclid=IwAR23KOOIx79x8UmOOSdhQRWoibZU5qCtMDysI9bv GYCG3uWd3m_J57-np_Y

[Messenger]

Thanks Carol. That actually confirms it for me, Relentless Me was definitely behind the leader and although the leader was off the pegs, Kate DID NOT have room to go up Relentless Me's inside without going inside several pegs. Who cares if she had a full head of steam up, that does not mean you can just be a bulldozer

[Messenger]

Luckily WA stewards are not paid by the word or else they would need a second job

http://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=GP040222

[Messenger]

Raymond Walker, the trainer of top 2021 2yo Mister Rea has been disqualified for 4½ mths and the horse has lost its win from the Breeders Challenge heat on September 14

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=51585

Maybe fortunately the horse was withdrawn from the rest of the series with a quarter crack

[Messenger]

Wondering where Jack Laugher has got to, I looked up the Suspended Driver list (the only place I find this is on Harnessweb)
Jack is due back from 3 weeks suspension today
But while browsing the list, I noticed the longest suspension is Leroy O'Brien
Leroy got 9 mths a couple of weeks ago for a cobalt offence from over a year ago
It is funny how the decision comes across as being so apologetic for suspending him

https://integrity.thetrots.com.au/news/articles/vrt-hearing-leroy-obrien/

[Messenger]

Nathan Carroll gets Life

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=51682

[Showgrounds]

Nathan Carroll gets Life

http://www.harness.org.au/media-room/news-article/?news_id=51682

A bit of detective work required on our part to join the dots from today's story back to the one HRNSW issued on 2 October 2017 -

https://www.hrnsw.com.au/news/1865/trainer-nathan-carroll---inquiries

[Showgrounds]

The stewards dealt with Jason Lee and Daryl Douglas on Saturday night after they turned the previous week's Group 1 Australian Trotting Grand Prix into an equine Demolition Derby. I can't help but feel both got off light considering the damage they caused.

https://www.harness.org.au/racing/stewards-reports/stewards-reports-detail/?mc=MX050322