Acceptances for Menangle

[mark diegutis]

The horses were all originally nominated under B.McCarthy. After Luke was disaqualified today, HRNSW said they were not convinced that this could work and said that a decision will be made by the Board on Monday on whether B.Mccarthy can take over training duties.

As nominations had already been taken, HRNSW decided to draw those horses into the field and to contact all owners of those horses and give them 2 options:

1. scratch without penalty; or
2. transfer the horse to and Race with a completely different trainer

Thanks Harvey . That answers alot of questions . HRNSW have done a very good job then . That gives everyone concerned a completely fair go . Thankfully for you HRV have looked at it differently and accepted B.McCarthy's nominations . Good luck

[p plater]

I would think that HRNSW policy on DISQUALIFICATIONS – TRANSFER OF HORSES is being read by many at the moment!!

http://www.hrnsw.com.au/assets/files...f%20Horses.pdf

Obviously, Victoria don't adopt the same policy.

[Starship Captain]

IMO he is just unlucky getting this positive.
The trainers job is to win? To do this they must walk a line and always push the limits. What is the big deal, it's not like he was fixing race's with the stewards.

[mark diegutis]

[QUOTE=jimmy777;20811]I would think that HRNSW policy on DISQUALIFICATIONS – TRANSFER OF HORSES is being read by many at the moment!!

Hi Jimmy . At the time of acceptances there was no disqualification as such . He was found guilty on Monday but wasn't sentenced . In theory he may have only been fined so they had to take the horses nominations . HRNSW came up with a great solution so that the owners weren't penalised . I think they have handled it really well .

[aussiebreno]

IMO he is just unlucky getting this positive.
The trainers job is to win? To do this they must walk a line and always push the limits. What is the big deal, it's not like he was fixing race's with the stewards.

So I can come into your house and steal your TV. Whats the big deal...I didn't steal your car......

[Starship Captain]

As long as you don't get caught and you promise to take my wife with you.

Come on Aussiebreno what world do you live in?

[aussiebreno]

As long as you don't get caught and you promise to take my wife with you.

Come on Aussiebreno what world do you live in?

Not worth it!
Ok yeah, I get where you are coming from......but it still isn't acceptable in my books. You are entitled to you opinion though.

[Starship Captain]

If I have to choose a trainer for my horse what are the requirements that need to be filled?

1-They must be winning
2-??

I need help with this.

[mightymo]

Thanks Harvey . That answers alot of questions . HRNSW have done a very good job then . That gives everyone concerned a completely fair go . Thankfully for you HRV have looked at it differently and accepted B.McCarthy's nominations . Good luck

HRV have applied the exact same policy as HRNSW. Their fields came out before the NSW ones and they just havent updated the fields. If we want Sixpence to race on Fri, she will need to be under the care of another trainer as well

[aussiebreno]

HRV have applied the exact same policy as HRNSW. Their fields came out before the NSW ones and they just havent updated the fields. If we want Sixpence to race on Fri, she will need to be under the care of another trainer as well

Will understand if you skip this question, but what is your though process their in regards to changing trainers or sticking with wherever McCarthys horses go?