G'day fellas,
Interestingly, looking at it all purely from a Southern Hemisphere perspective, neither of those sires has left a son that has been able to make a real impact down here.
Easily the best siring effort recorded by a son of Western Hanover to stand stud down here has been Badlands Hanover & I think it's fair to say that overall he has done a tradesman-like job only and that he did so most notably with initially subtantial Nevele R client/broodmare support so how much of all that was him and how much of it was as a result of the quality and number of mares he covered in his initial seasons is wide open to conjecture.
As far as sons of Camluck are concerned, they've been an across-the-board washout and on both sides of the Pacific to boot. For the sheer number of foals that he has produced over the years it is quite surprising to me that he has thus far proven incapable of extending his line in any meaningful way.